Eliminate one female singer

[BryceC]

I agree with the sentiment...but I couldn't get rid of Madonna due to some of her great singles in the 80s/90s. I never really cared for her but can't discount many of her songs.

I’m the exact opposite, I’ll never intentionally listen to a Madonna song ever.

 

[nfrine]

Roseanne Barr

 

[clonedude]

I took it as we would be getting rid of their music... in that aspect... Madonna has by far the best music on the list... and Beyonce the worst IMO.

 

[WIBadger]

All time library

In that case, Mariah Carey for me

 

[BryceC]

She suck’s. Bring it

Random Mariah Carey thing - Always be my Baby came on after a particularly brutal Iowa State loss once and it kind of became something we did after losses.

 

[somecyguy]

You asked.... Beyonce is a POS. She treats everyone terribly... roadies, band members, backup dancers, sound board, EVERYONE. Nobody likes her and they all avoid her.

Madonna... very similar. Disrespectful to road crew and the locals that work security in the arenas. Most nights won't go onstage until after 11 pm. Very mouthy and curses a lot.

Mariah Carey similar to Beyonce but not as bad to the crew.

He hasn't worked with Taylor, so no story there. He hasn't toured with Rhianna either.

He has toured with several others not on the list... but he says hands down Beyonce is the worst.

That seems to track. Swift's music is like finger nails on a chalk board to me, but she seems to be much more down to earth than the others. The others are just divas.

 

[cyfanatic]

I’m the exact opposite, I’ll never intentionally listen to a Madonna song ever.

I never liked Madonna as a "celebrity"...but songs like this one I like:

 

[madguy30]

It begs to question if some others aren't there without Madonna, but maybe not.

I think Mariah carries more than Beyonce or Rhianna for iconic songs.

Swift actually has some pretty introspective lyrics at times.

She's super talented but I think I'm cutting Rhianna.

I realize she had a lot more but 'Umbrella ella ella eh eh eh' is some pretty bad stuff.

 

[simply1]

You asked.... Beyonce is a POS. She treats everyone terribly... roadies, band members, backup dancers, sound board, EVERYONE. Nobody likes her and they all avoid her.

Madonna... very similar. Disrespectful to road crew and the locals that work security in the arenas. Most nights won't go onstage until after 11 pm. Very mouthy and curses a lot.

Mariah Carey similar to Beyonce but not as bad to the crew.

He hasn't worked with Taylor, so no story there. He hasn't toured with Rhianna either.

He has toured with several others not on the list... but he says hands down Beyonce is the worst.

Taylor at least seems to pay nice bonuses

 

[cydsho]

I'm old enough to easily remember all of Madonna's early stuff and she was fine. Although I haven't considered her relevant for more than 20 years.
Mariah Carey similar but without the dumb Christmas song she's irrelevant now.
Swift at least is musician probably and some songs can be enjoyable.
Don't get Rhianna.
Beyonce's music is over produced and nonsensical.

 

[Gonzo]

It begs to question if some others aren't there without Madonna, but maybe not.

I think Mariah carries more than Beyonce or Rhianna for iconic songs.

Swift actually has some pretty introspective lyrics at times.

She's super talented but I think I'm cutting Rhianna.

I realize she had a lot more but 'Umbrella ella ella eh eh eh' is some pretty bad stuff.

Madonna's not there without Cher.

Lady Gaga's not there without Madonna.

They all owe the ones who blazed the trail before them.

 

[Clone9]

Can we get rid of more than one?

 

[Sigmapolis]

I'll die happy if I never hear that damn Christmas song again.

 

[KnappShack]

All of the above

 

[BCClone]

Taylor Swift. I’m so sick and tired of her. Get her out of here.

May finally be able to watch a chiefs game then.

 

[Sigmapolis]

May finally be able to watch a chiefs game then.

 

[Cyclonepride]

I don't care for any of them really

 

[BWRhasnoAC]

I’m the exact opposite, I’ll never intentionally listen to a Madonna song ever.

Her music sucks.

 

[BWRhasnoAC]

Madonna's not there without Cher.

Lady Gaga's not there without Madonna.

They all owe the ones who blazed the trail before them.

They all wish they were Janis Joplin. Aretha Franklin.

 

[Gonzo]

They all wish they were Janis Joplin. Aretha Franklin.

I wouldn't argue that. They were more about shock aesthetics and pushing social boundaries. Janis and Aretha were more about pure musical talent and performing from their gut.