Eliminate one female singer

Which one are you eliminating?


  • Total voters
    253

JP4CY

Lord, beer me strength.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
80,542
106,495
113
Testifying
Listening to the Odd Couple on the radio.
They brought up the top 5 female selling artists of all time. One has to go, who is it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: cytor
Madonna and TS have some great songs. Rhianna decent songs but she’s super hot. Mariah is blah but at least she has that Christmas song I guess. I can’t think of any redeeming qualities for Beyoncé or her music.

But I guess the question is whether we’re eliminating their music library or eliminating the person currently…because Madonna is kind of repulsive now, but her music library is good.
 
Madonna and TS have some great songs. Rhianna decent songs but she’s super hot. Mariah is blah but at least she has that Christmas song I guess. I can’t think of any redeeming qualities for Beyoncé or her music.

But I guess the question is whether we’re eliminating their music library or eliminating the person currently…because Madonna is kind of repulsive now, but her music library is good.
Is this in their primes or currently?
All time library
 
Madonna's the only answer here. Approaching 70 years old and still trying to be the sex kitten who hangs with all the 20somethings. Pretty pathetic.

I agree with the sentiment...but I couldn't get rid of Madonna due to some of her great singles in the 80s/90s. I never really cared for her but can't discount many of her songs.
 
Easy Beyoncé then. I thought her music was better with destinys child than anything she’s done since. But for some reason she gets the royal treatment.
I agree completely. I’ll never forgive Beyoncé for butchering songs in the live action lion king
 
You say one bad word about Mariah Carey and I’ll cut you to pieces.
survivor-panama.gif
 
Dish the dirt or GTFO!
You asked.... Beyonce is a POS. She treats everyone terribly... roadies, band members, backup dancers, sound board, EVERYONE. Nobody likes her and they all avoid her.

Madonna... very similar. Disrespectful to road crew and the locals that work security in the arenas. Most nights won't go onstage until after 11 pm. Very mouthy and curses a lot.

Mariah Carey similar to Beyonce but not as bad to the crew.

He hasn't worked with Taylor, so no story there. He hasn't toured with Rhianna either.

He has toured with several others not on the list... but he says hands down Beyonce is the worst.