This is why Prohm must go........

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,847
41,423
113
Waukee
After all the **** you and I took for questioning Prohm from day 1 and here we are. Happy New Year my man

This is an imperfect analogy -- but this is starting to feel like the Rhoads era.

Rhoads came in with some talent on the shelf leftover from Chizik's recruiting. Rhoads never had the kind of talent that Prohm did in the relative sense (nor did he have nearly the same level of expectations), but they did well with what was left when they came into their respective programs and built up a lot of goodwill.

Rhoads then rebuilt the roster in his image, and he had a few good years. He never "broke through" to something truly memorable or transcendent, though (such as what Campbell has done with the program the last three years), and we felt there were some years of missed opportunities. Rhoads oftentimes had defenses that could be very competitive but the team just looked lost on offense. Then the bottom on defense dropped out.

And then it fell apart. Hard.

Rhoads built up goodwill with somebody else's talent and gave us some great memories, but he was unable to create a sustainable and respectable winner on his own.

Prohm did well with the returning talent. He then rebuilt the program in his image and had some modest success. And now, after that... well. Yikes.

That had a K-State feel about it.
 

tzjung

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 2, 2007
2,258
1,478
113
45
Ankeny, IA
I remember posting early in this thread outlining that I could understand how people could be frustrated with Prohm and his coaching style. I then got attacked by Prohm's White Knight / Attack Dog @CatStevens who said I was just part of the 'Crewe' who hated Steve.

At that point I wasn't, but the Iowa game and this game have convinced me. I've seen all I need to see, Prohm has to go. At this point I can not fathom how this season can be redeemed.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: demoncore1031

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,174
55,076
113
This is an imperfect analogy -- but this is starting to feel like the Rhoads era.

Rhoads came in with some talent on the shelf leftover from Chizik's recruiting. Rhoads never had the kind of talent that Prohm did in the relative sense (nor did he have nearly the same level of expectations), but they did well with what was left when they came into their respective programs and built up a lot of goodwill.

Rhoads then rebuilt the roster in his image, and he had a few good years. He never "broke through" to something truly memorable or transcendent, though (such as what Campbell has done with the program the last three years), and we felt there were some years of missed opportunities. Rhoads oftentimes had defenses that could be very competitive but the team just looked lost on offense. Then the bottom on defense dropped out.

And then it fell apart. Hard.

Rhoads built up goodwill with somebody else's talent and gave us some great memories, but he was unable to create a sustainable and respectable winner on his own.

Prohm did well with the returning talent. He then rebuilt the program in his image and had some modest success. And now, after that... well. Yikes.

That had a K-State feel about it.

More of a NDSU '14 feel or was that the Iowa game, or the TCU game in Hilton last season?
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: tzjung

Cy$

Well-Known Member
Sep 1, 2011
24,072
6,016
113
Ames
This is an imperfect analogy -- but this is starting to feel like the Rhoads era.

Rhoads came in with some talent on the shelf leftover from Chizik's recruiting. Rhoads never had the kind of talent that Prohm did in the relative sense (nor did he have nearly the same level of expectations), but they did well with what was left when they came into their respective programs and built up a lot of goodwill.

Rhoads then rebuilt the roster in his image, and he had a few good years. He never "broke through" to something truly memorable or transcendent, though (such as what Campbell has done with the program the last three years), and we felt there were some years of missed opportunities. Rhoads oftentimes had defenses that could be very competitive but the team just looked lost on offense. Then the bottom on defense dropped out.

And then it fell apart. Hard.

Rhoads built up goodwill with somebody else's talent and gave us some great memories, but he was unable to create a sustainable and respectable winner on his own.

Prohm did well with the returning talent. He then rebuilt the program in his image and had some modest success. And now, after that... well. Yikes.

That had a K-State feel about it.
I said the Iowa loss was equivalent to CPR's Kansas St. loss except Prohm will be here awhile due to his contract. I still believe that.
 

CloneFan4

Well-Known Member
Aug 5, 2010
5,882
5,593
113
West Des Moines
This is an imperfect analogy -- but this is starting to feel like the Rhoads era.

Rhoads came in with some talent on the shelf leftover from Chizik's recruiting. Rhoads never had the kind of talent that Prohm did in the relative sense (nor did he have nearly the same level of expectations), but they did well with what was left when they came into their respective programs and built up a lot of goodwill.

Rhoads then rebuilt the roster in his image, and he had a few good years. He never "broke through" to something truly memorable or transcendent, though (such as what Campbell has done with the program the last three years), and we felt there were some years of missed opportunities. Rhoads oftentimes had defenses that could be very competitive but the team just looked lost on offense. Then the bottom on defense dropped out.

And then it fell apart. Hard.

Rhoads built up goodwill with somebody else's talent and gave us some great memories, but he was unable to create a sustainable and respectable winner on his own.

Prohm did well with the returning talent. He then rebuilt the program in his image and had some modest success. And now, after that... well. Yikes.

That had a K-State feel about it.

Sorry for what I said when I was hungry
 

isufbcurt

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2006
27,460
44,357
113
46
Newton
@isufbcurt you've always thought my opinions on Steve were bad. How you feeling right now?

We lost a game we should never lose, it sucks. Other than that it has no effect on me. I'll continue to go to games and buy season tickets.

Sorry it took me so long to reply I was actually at the game.
 
Last edited:
  • Winner
Reactions: VeloClone

ForbinsAscynt

Well-Known Member
Dec 8, 2014
5,044
6,298
113
So I normally wouldn’t post this but I just saw prohm at the gas station looking about as pissed as humanly possible. I didn’t say a word but I was wearing an isu sweatshirt and he looked at me a few times almost waiting for some interaction. I thought about saying something encouraging but what can you say after a loss like that.
 
Last edited:

Rabbuk

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2011
56,961
46,116
113
So I normally would post this but I just saw prohm at the gas station looking about as pissed as humanly possible. I didn’t say a word but I was wearing an isu sweatshirt and he looked at me a few times almost waiting for some interaction. I thought about saying something encouraging but what can you say after a loss like that.
giphy.gif
 

tim_redd

Well-Known Member
Mar 29, 2006
13,873
8,872
113
42
Ankeny
So I normally would post this but I just saw prohm at the gas station looking about as pissed as humanly possible. I didn’t say a word but I was wearing an isu sweatshirt and he looked at me a few times almost waiting for some interaction. I thought about saying something encouraging but what can you say after a loss like that.
Are you trying to say he was out of gas?
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron