Is it really coaching?

"Coaching" in four words
1. Recruiting
2. Development
3. Preparation
4. Adjustments
 
It is coaching. Part of coaching is developing players. Has Sam Richardson gotten any better since he got on campus? Grant Rohach was an Elite 11 QB coming out of HS... and he has probably regressed since he arrived in Ames.

Another big part of coaching is evaluating talent... Mike Warren hardly played in the first 2 games and since has gone off running the football. How is it the guy wasn't the starter from the get go? On the TCU telecast the announcers said that Warren was described by the staff as a "Saturday night guy" meaning he doesn't show anything in practice or scrimmages but shows up on Saturday night and plays great. Does anyone really believe that? That sounds more like a good cover for finally playing a kid and he lights it up and the staff now needs an excuse as to why he never saw the field before that.

ISU has some talent at key positions but if the schemes or game plans that the staff puts in place week to week doesn't put these guys in the right position to make plays then there isn't much they can do. (See Wally and the 12 yard cushions our corners play)

Looks like our staff needs to attend The Bill Belichek How to Win School in the off season.
 
In last week's press conference after the Tech game, Coach threw the team under the bus. He told the world that his team was scared of Tech. This week, after the TCU game, Coach said Lanning's pass should have never been thrown. He also said Sam Richardson's performance was "spot on".


The problem is coaching. Period. End of story.
 
Coaching and adjustments are huge in college football. You telling me Memphis has more talent than Ole Miss? Hell no.

No doubt talent is very important and talent wins a lot but when u don't have talent then you better have great coaching to compensate. When u have great coaching and talent then you play for NCs. At Iowa State you need 2 things...1- A stud coach who can develop players and make great in game adjustments and see them to make and 2- a helluva strength program. We lack both badly. Chris Doyle works magic every single year and takes kids who were 230lbs and turns them into NFL draft picks..every year...every year. These aren't 4-5 star kids either.
 
In last week's press conference after the Tech game, Coach threw the team under the bus. He told the world that his team was scared of Tech. This week, after the TCU game, Coach said Lanning's pass should have never been thrown. He also said Sam Richardson's performance was "spot on".


The problem is coaching. Period. End of story.

I watched presser after TCU game I didn't see CPR say Lanning shouldn't throw that ball?
 
Mid-Season Grades for the Staff
1. Recruiting - B (ISU has talent… see Warren, Lazard, Jones, Tucker, Pierson)
2. Development - incomplete
3. Preparation - D- (still coming out flat to begin games and second halves)
4. Adjustments - F-
 
Kaz Kazadi down at Baylor has been doing incredible things with the S&C program. Those guys improve immensely.
 
Yes, it is about coaching. The second half of the Iowa game was 100% the coaches not making the right adjustments to the ones Iowa's defensive coordinators made. I would say the TCU game would be the same thing, although I don't think it would have mattered. ISU wasn't going to outscore TCU anyway. The Texas Tech game, well, I put that on one coach and one qb.
I have noticed that other teams seem to make the adjustments necessary at halftime and we never seem to make them ourselves. If we did, we would always be getting outplayed during the second half. Sometimes we are within striking distance at halftime and they make adjustments and we can't do anything that was working during the first half of the game.
 
I think CPR time here is done. I am as unhappy about being 2-4 as anyone. Keep in mind we were tied with UI in the 4th and made a bone-head play. We missed a FG to win at Toledo. The teams that beat us are a combined 25-2, but we have to be able to be a decent team. I still don't think UI is top 15 team, they just won't play anyone good for a long time on their schedule. Not like they have to play a top 10 offense, followed by the number 3 team, then the number 2 team. But we still need to be able to win more than 2-3 games a year. Who is left on our schedule that anyone thinks we will beat, not could beat? Our coaches don't seem to be able to recruit the talent they need or have the talent they have get better. Like I said, I think a coaching change will happen at the end of the season.