Higher NBA Draft Pick Royce or HB?

If we can agree that the CCL is stiffer competition than HS and having seen Royce in the CCL and HB in H.S. and 1 year at NC, who is the higher NBA draft pick next year if both leave?

I have seen both play in person as many of us now have. I give the edge to Royce if he shows that he can defend the 4 and the 5. The offense is obiously there.

I'm a big Royce fan, but you can't go any higher than #1 where HB is likely going.
 
Last I checked the NBA likes their players to be strong. The guy isn't carrying around 30 pounds of gut, it's pretty much all muscle.

People get so hung up on height it's hilarious. If a guy can play, he can play. Royce is listed at 6'8" and I know there are always the message board psychotics who feel they can accurately judge a persons height or weight by eye sight from 50 yards away who feel that he is shorter than that, but shockingly, I'm going to go with what ISU has him listed at.

Off the top of my head here are some PF's of comparable size who have done well for themselves in the NBA:

Charles Barkley 6'5"
Larry Johnson 6'6"
Dennis Rodman 6'6"*
Elton Brand 6'8"
Jason Maxiell 6'8"
Elton Brand 6'8"
Carlos Boozer 6'9"
Shawn Marion 6'7"
Chuck Hayes 6'6"*
Carl Landry 6'9"
Anthony Mason 6'7"
Dejaun Blair, 6'5"
Paul Millsap, 6'6"
Clarence Weatherspoon, 6'6"
Ben Wallace, 6'7"* (his height by his own admission)
Wes Unseld, 6'7"*

* - Played a good amount of center

Common factor between these guys and Royce (barring the outlier in Marion) is that they are/were all extremely strong. To say that he needs to drop 30 pounds or he isn't tall enough to play in the front court in the NBA is all just ridiculous.


Shawn Marion is not a PF. While he did a nice job playing D on Lebron James, a SF, he has played lots of 2 - guard and 3 if you go back to his Phoenix days.

Rodman was a bit of a freak. Early in his career, he got by on quicks - one of the few guys that could go step for step with James Worthy's spin move. His quick bounce allowed him to rebound with bigger guys. His job became to defend and rebound, but you are right that his height didn't stop him from playing bigger guys.

Most of the altitude-challenged folks on your list were one of a couple of things - either really thick or great offensive players. Barkley could score and rebound, but he wasn't confused often as a good onside defender. There was a great piece on ESPN one night when Charles said he scared Michael Jordan once. Jordan's version was he took one look at Barkley trying to get ready to play on the perimeter, started laughing, and had to pass the ball until he could get his composure back. Barkley could certainly rebound. Unseld played in a different era, but like Wallace, used his hair to look bigger than he was. Those guys were not just thick and strong, they had a bit of nasty too.

Not saying White can't have a shot, but Fizer couldn't stick, and he was thick, strong, a bit nasty and a scorer.
 
Shawn Marion is not a PF. While he did a nice job playing D on Lebron James, a SF, he has played lots of 2 - guard and 3 if you go back to his Phoenix days.

Rodman was a bit of a freak. Early in his career, he got by on quicks - one of the few guys that could go step for step with James Worthy's spin move. His quick bounce allowed him to rebound with bigger guys. His job became to defend and rebound, but you are right that his height didn't stop him from playing bigger guys.

Most of the altitude-challenged folks on your list were one of a couple of things - either really thick or great offensive players. Barkley could score and rebound, but he wasn't confused often as a good onside defender. There was a great piece on ESPN one night when Charles said he scared Michael Jordan once. Jordan's version was he took one look at Barkley trying to get ready to play on the perimeter, started laughing, and had to pass the ball until he could get his composure back. Barkley could certainly rebound. Unseld played in a different era, but like Wallace, used his hair to look bigger than he was. Those guys were not just thick and strong, they had a bit of nasty too.

Not saying White can't have a shot, but Fizer couldn't stick, and he was thick, strong, a bit nasty and a scorer.

Marion started playing the 4 when he was with Miami and has been getting a lot of time there ever since, thats why I included him.

I think we can all agree that White lands in the thick category (muscle wise, not Oliver Miller wise).

To have a lasting career in the NBA a player has to have one aspect of the game they do really, really well. Be it a banger inside, a facilitator, a scorer, etc. If White can elevate his game to a serviceable level at any one of those aspects, he could very well have a long career in the NBA.
 
Because someone got excited about an upcoming season, so the legion of downers decided to knock him down a peg.

Also for all you geniuses dismissing the guys question, speculation isn't fact. Will HB get drafted higher? Probably. Is it a done deal? Of course not.
Or people just live in this thing called reality...:yes:
 
Or people just live in this thing called reality...:yes:

Actually it's an opinion, not a reality. Opinions don't hold much weight. Like I might give my opinion that the use of emoticons or "smilies" when typing is strictly for teenaged girls. Now that opinion seems like a reality to me, but I doubt you would agree.
 
Marion started playing the 4 when he was with Miami and has been getting a lot of time there ever since, thats why I included him.

I think we can all agree that White lands in the thick category (muscle wise, not Oliver Miller wise).

To have a lasting career in the NBA a player has to have one aspect of the game they do really, really well. Be it a banger inside, a facilitator, a scorer, etc. If White can elevate his game to a serviceable level at any one of those aspects, he could very well have a long career in the NBA.

100% agree. The true greats are more well rounded by being excellent in several areas, but the way to stick in the league is to do something really well - you will stick longer than someone who is rounded, but not spectacular anywhere.
 
HB played in the CCL as a high school kid. Royce is 2 years past high school and is bigger than everybody else. HB has scored 40 points in a college game. Royce has never scored in a college game. I think Royce will be a great college player who doesn't project super high on draft boards.
 
While I agree that it's way too premature to have this kind of discussion, and that HB is clearly the more highly regarded NBA prospect, I thought I'd throw this out there. For the sake of argument only.
Where was Derrick Williams projected at this time last season? I'm honestly not sure, I'd never heard of him before last February. Both RW and Williams were big HS recruits. They seem to be a similar size and play a similar style (similar, not identical, we don't need height and weight stats listed here), playing for teams that had potential but not too many expectations. One huge season later and Williams is the Pac 10 player of the year and second overall pick. Not saying it will happen, only that everyone would have dismissed a Derrick Williams vs HB draft discussion as ridiculous before last season too. Whenever Barnes declares, he'll be one of the top picks and may well have gone ahead of Williams had he come out this year. Just solely for the sake of argument I'm saying that crazy things can happen and no one should be acting like anything's set in stone.
Clearly the OP was more impressed with RW's performance in the CCL than he was in watching HB in the CIML, and if we can ignore the wild conjecture regarding draft position, it might be a valid point. HB had 2 other D1 (barely) players on his team beating up on horribly overmatched teams that had none. So if we ignore the AAU circuit and the hype and the perceived potential of the respective players, it's not that crazy to say White looked like the better player.

I realize I'm helping you make your point, but I want you to make a factually correct point.
How Derrick Williams went from unheralded to All-American - The Dagger - NCAAB Blog - Yahoo! Sports

You had me up until the part where we have to ignore HB dominating AAU - I'll add the McD's All-American Game and getting his team a 2 seed in the NCAA tournament this year. He's a top 3 pick and the original question was obviously the result of alot of drugs and heavy drinking on the OP's part.

With that said, I really think Royce is going to be great for us.
 
For the people using Fizer as a comparison, I agree that he had lots of holes in his game.

But the biggest problem he had was that he was drafted by the Bulls right after they had the rookie of the year in Brand at the same position.

They absolutely choked on that pick. Had another team, that didn't have their franchise player at the same damn position, would have picked Fizer, he would have had many more opportunities to play.

Now he still couldn't guard anybody, and he had a lot of attitude problems, but he was playing well at the time that he hurt his knee. But he was severely handicapped by the fact that the Bulls were the most dysfunctional franchise
 
While I agree that it's way too premature to have this kind of discussion, and that HB is clearly the more highly regarded NBA prospect, I thought I'd throw this out there. For the sake of argument only.
Where was Derrick Williams projected at this time last season? I'm honestly not sure, I'd never heard of him before last February. Both RW and Williams were big HS recruits. They seem to be a similar size and play a similar style (similar, not identical, we don't need height and weight stats listed here), playing for teams that had potential but not too many expectations. One huge season later and Williams is the Pac 10 player of the year and second overall pick. Not saying it will happen, only that everyone would have dismissed a Derrick Williams vs HB draft discussion as ridiculous before last season too. Whenever Barnes declares, he'll be one of the top picks and may well have gone ahead of Williams had he come out this year. Just solely for the sake of argument I'm saying that crazy things can happen and no one should be acting like anything's set in stone.
Clearly the OP was more impressed with RW's performance in the CCL than he was in watching HB in the CIML, and if we can ignore the wild conjecture regarding draft position, it might be a valid point. HB had 2 other D1 (barely) players on his team beating up on horribly overmatched teams that had none. So if we ignore the AAU circuit and the hype and the perceived potential of the respective players, it's not that crazy to say White looked like the better player.

Well done sir. The whole premise of my post is that many fellow CF'ers have knowledge of Royce's skills and I was asking them to make their judgement on what they have seen with their own eyes. The same question could have been posed on an AZ Wildcat message board last year.

I'll add to it that many posters have stated where HB would have gone in this summer's draft. Keep in mind that this was one of the worst draft classess in a long time.
 
its obviously Royce he's easily going top 3 next year. I mean he's proven himself in the gauntlet that is the CCL. I mean come on going against some HS players as well as a few d3 players obviuosly White has proven himself to NBA GMs everywhere. What is the ACC is that some sort of mid-major joke!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Creed
Well done sir. The whole premise of my post is that many fellow CF'ers have knowledge of Royce's skills and I was asking them to make their judgement on what they have seen with their own eyes. The same question could have been posed on an AZ Wildcat message board last year.

I'll add to it that many posters have stated where HB would have gone in this summer's draft. Keep in mind that this was one of the worst draft classess in a long time.

The draft would have been a lot more highly regarded had Barnes been in it.
 
I think it is officially time for a big fat BUMP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Are you guys ready to have this conversation yet?