Which state is most Midwestern?

It's really not a bad drive, especially after doing 20 to Ames so many times. Good luck getting a spot! Sometimes people post them in the Wisconsin State Park FB group if you're in there.

We go later in summer to the Lake side. Trying to convince spouse we need a little cottage there or over by Viroqua but he says no.
I've had luck doing it in the past. Especially a week or so out, cancellations will start happening often. Every year I tell myself to get a site as soon as they open, every year I forget... It's easy to cancel reservations, which is nice if plans fall through, but I think it also allows people to grab all the sites early, and then cancel later if they want.

We keep half-ass looking for a small property to build a little "getaway" cabin type house, but haven't tried very hard.
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: cowgirl836
Last edited:
  • Friendly
Reactions: cowgirl836
I've always considered Minnesota as part of the "Great Lakes" territory - along with Wisconsin and Michigan, and not Midwest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StClone
Iowans ******* love the Dells meanwhile I'm like give me Driftless all day. And some DC. Which, props to Illinois, they also go to DC.
I went to the Dells once when I was around 7 and haven't been back since, but it was memorable for a little kid. Riding on the ducks was fun and a little terrifying, I was swarmed by some small woodland creatures while trying to feed them crackers at some kind of petting zoo, and I'm still not sure what I witnessed on our trip to the House on the Rock. That's about all I remember, but given I'm in my 40s it was one of the more memorable trips I had at that age.
 
  • Like
  • Friendly
Reactions: NWICY and StClone
Southwestern Wisconsin and a tiny bit of NW Illinois contain the only true Driftless Landform. Iowa has "Driftless Topography," and was glaciated by an earlier ice mass to a proven extent.



The only pretty part of Illinois, if I do say so myself. But it is wild how quickly it flattens out once you leave it, at least where I grew up. I think in Wisconsin in flattens a bit more gradually.
 
Iowa is probably the most consistent of Midwest states throughout. While there is some variance from north to south, some east to west but not as much IMO, it’s pretty similar style of life and landscape use throughout. Many of the other states have some more drastic change through their state.

This also takes into account that our large metro is DM, which is the smallest metro of the other Midwest states out there, and isn’t really what people think of when the big cities are mentioned.
 
P
Iowa is probably the most consistent of Midwest states throughout. While there is some variance from north to south, some east to west but not as much IMO, it’s pretty similar style of life and landscape use throughout. Many of the other states have some more drastic change through their state.

This also takes into account that our large metro is DM, which is the smallest metro of the other Midwest states out there, and isn’t really what people think of when the big cities are mentioned.
The fact that all the other "midwest" areas of the states around us adjoin the Iowa border kind of tells you all you need to know.
 
Just for everyone's reference, the official definition of "Midwest" by the Federal Census Bureau is Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska, South Dakota, North Dakota.

They break that down into two sub-regions based on which side of the Mississippi you're on. Outside of far southern Missouri, I think what they call the "West North Central" contains Iowa's closest analogs.

At the end of the day Iowa is the only Midwestern state that doesn't share overlap with a neighboring region, and that makes it the most "Midwestern" state in my book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VeloClone
That would be silly, because there’s no question, it absolutely is.

I don't include it. Most of lower Michigan either. The Census Bureau disagrees.

IMO, northern Oklahoma fits better than most of Ohio. Eastern Colorado feels like an extension of the Midwest too.
Where is that Toledo FB dad that started that argument?