What I mean is that CMC relied on returnees, JC’s and transfers to carry the receiving corps the first few years. Than after the Fiesta Bowl win, they turned up HS WR recruiting a notch. Or two.
Transfer Portal Tracker
- Thread starter CoachHines3
- Start date
I get what you mean. It just isn't supported by what's actually happened, at least so far.
You mean, aside from what’s actually happened, by them signing more athletic and higher rated wideouts—as opposed to “take a stab in the dark” guys? Gotcha.
Brahmer and Stevo celebrating running downfield after destroying a couple guys is great.
I mean, that's just not true. There is no one we've recruited that was ranked higher than Scates and the one who was close is gone. The guys purported to be athletic in some way are either gone (Adams) or on defense Tampa, Porter, Cooper). Beni is the only one who would qualify there and it's too early to tell but he's rated the same as Porter and Sean Shaw.
Ratings. Like they are never wrong. Walkons prove the ratings wrong every year.
Talent is nothing without development. We kicked Texas's @$$ multiple times without any real star power. And they're always loaded with blue chip talent.
The West Point cadet Isaiah Alston who entered the transfer portal last weekend and Iowa State offered, got several P5 offers immediately including Kansas and Houston, but they have quickly tapered off to FCS teams. Rumor is that he won't be able to separate from West Point Academy without fulfilling his signed 6 yr commitment to the US Army.
KidSilverhair
Well-Known Member
Hmm, I never thought about service academy guys and the transfer portal, but when you enter a military academy you are pledging to serve in that branch.
I worked at a company where someone was in West Point, but left after two years. He said he had to pay $50k for each year he was there to leave.
Maybe because this player is in his Junior Season, it may be too late for him to leave? But I don't know.
From what I'm finding on the matter, West Point football recruits are given until the start of their junior year to make a pledge for a full commission in the Army academy, and according to reports, Alston did that. A West Point spokesman said all cadets follow the same rules when it comes to completing their agreed upon term of service. So this one might be interesting to watch.
Well that’s not true. ISU has had a JC or Transfer lead them in receiving yards every year since 2020. There’s a reason we’ve offered so many WRs in the portal these last few years and there’s a reason we’re trying to add another transfer/JC WR to this class before next year
UNLV rebel girl would lose the rest of her **** if this happened
You literally repeated what I said.
And the reason we’re trying to add one more receiver to the room now is to add experience at the top. This is a development program. Any of those talented youngsters (Ngoyi, Parkes, Black, Essex, Eskildsen or Overby) can be expected to break in with twenty or thirty catches next season, not the fifty or so Scheelhaase would like to see a veteran add to complement Higgins and Noel.
Then in ‘25, those guys will be ready to take on bigger roles.
I didn't bring up ratings. I was told we were bringing in higher rated guys and we just aren't. None of any of this is opinion. Objectively, and I posted the numbers, we have a very low hit rate among WR recruits and up through the 2022 class, absolutely none of those trends are changing like he said. This isn't an opinion if you just look at all the recruits and where their career went.
And again, it hasn't really mattered to this point because of transfer and JUCO recruiting at the position so it's not a big deal. It's just what has gone on.
Recruiting is an inexact science. So you post that you have been told we are bringing in higher rated players. Then state that you didn’t bring up ratings. You make no sense.
Forgot who I was talking to.
He said we were bringing in higher rated players that are more athletic. I then said, participation has not indicated that to be true and he was also wrong that we were actually bringing in higher rated players so neither thing he claimed in regard to WR recruiting was true. It makes sense if you read the whole discussion to have proper context.
