I don't think anyone will ever bypass Colton for me, but Sai is definitely up in the top ranks.
Survivor 48
- Thread starter CYdTracked
- Start date
Colton is an all timer. Mixed with his nice partner who died. I can’t stand that dude
Yes Colton by far the worst, most irritating survivor. The fact he was invited back for a second season is nauseating. Then Jeff does everything in his power to help him redeem himself and save face. But Colton just can't help but be an annoying, entitled, smug prick. When Jeff just threw his hands in the air and says you know what, you want to dig this hole go ahead. That is the best part of Colton being on Survivor.
Sai at least fought for her spot on survivor. She may be unbearable and delusional but at least she was fighting, planning, and scheming her way through the game.
Pleased with the votes. Sai on thw jury would have been bad, anyone that ever cast a vote for her probably would have no chance of getting her vote.
I really hope the strong players alliance holds up as would be nice to have multiple people at the end I'd be glad to see win.
I really hope the strong players alliance holds up as would be nice to have multiple people at the end I'd be glad to see win.
Colton by far is #1 on my list of all time most annoying players. He gave you not a single reason to like him and Jeff should have never let him play a 2nd time. Sai probably would make my top 10 list, not sure she'd be top 5 but closer to 5 than 10. This season has a lot more likable players than any in recent memory.
Agreed. Usually I can find a couple who I like. This season it's opposite there are a few I don't like and most of them are already gone.
So who is on your list of most annoying/hated Survivor players of all time? Feel free to comment or add your own list.
1. Colton - this is probably everyone's #1 I would guess. Annoying entitled prick that quit twice. Hope he eventually figured out how to be a decent human being after Survivor but I would not be surprised if he hasn't changed much. People like that usually are too blind to the person they are and live in their own reality.
2. "Secret Agent" Phillip - between the constant talking down to everyone he was around and what I called his disgusting "man panties" this guy was a real piece of work
3. Dan Spilo - goes down as one of the scummiest human beings to play the show. All the inappropriate touching even after he was called out on it a few times then gets removed from the game for inappropriate behavior towards someone on the production crew. What made me even more sick that season was some of the cast protecting him to further their own game instead of voting his ass off when it was obviously a problem. Janet tried to do the right thing and address it too and everyone just basically looked the other way.
4. Jonny Fairplay - lying about his grandmother's death to gain some sympathy gotta be one of the lowest things you can do. He just seemed like a guy that lacked character and would do anything.
5. Brandon Hantz - this guy had some serious demons. If it were not for his famous uncle Russel not sure he would have ever been cast for the show. Says a lot when you are so toxic that your tribe intentionally forfeits a challenge just to vote you out then doesn't even want to go to tribal and just unanimously votes him out after a tirade.
6. Coach - some may say he was likable, I found the whole "Dragon Slayer" stuff quite annoying. I do think he is a good guy but his place on this list has to do with his annoying antics more than anything.
7. Shantel "Shan" - From season 41, she tried so hard to play a villain and was quite annoying while doing it. That season was so bad too after season 40 was so good.
8. NaOnka - another person that lacked some decency. Had an obsession with Kelly's prosthetic leg and kept targeting her because of it. Ironically she wound up quitting with 11 days left that season.
9. Sai - she's more recent so I had to keep that in mind when coming up with my list as compared to everyone above I don't thing she ranks up there with some of the lack of decency as a human being. Yes she was annoying and played too hard too early then was a drama queen when things did not go her way but I don't doubt her character like most of the people above on the list.
10. Michael Skupin - This one I really have to think about, could make the argument he belongs higher on the list too. The first season he played he fell into the fire and had to be medically evacuated. The 2nd time he played he made it to final tribal. He probably gets more bad attention for what happened outside of survivor as he was convicted for fraud and a child sex offender but he wasn't exactly well liked the 2nd time he played either.
Elephant in the room: Russel Hantz. I'm sure many would put him on their top 10 but for me he was one of the best "old school" players that never won the game. Found his way to the final tribal twice but his deceptive ways never got him the jury votes to win as he burned too many bridges with the jury to get there. He was entertaining which is why he doesn't make this list for me.
1. Colton - this is probably everyone's #1 I would guess. Annoying entitled prick that quit twice. Hope he eventually figured out how to be a decent human being after Survivor but I would not be surprised if he hasn't changed much. People like that usually are too blind to the person they are and live in their own reality.
2. "Secret Agent" Phillip - between the constant talking down to everyone he was around and what I called his disgusting "man panties" this guy was a real piece of work
3. Dan Spilo - goes down as one of the scummiest human beings to play the show. All the inappropriate touching even after he was called out on it a few times then gets removed from the game for inappropriate behavior towards someone on the production crew. What made me even more sick that season was some of the cast protecting him to further their own game instead of voting his ass off when it was obviously a problem. Janet tried to do the right thing and address it too and everyone just basically looked the other way.
4. Jonny Fairplay - lying about his grandmother's death to gain some sympathy gotta be one of the lowest things you can do. He just seemed like a guy that lacked character and would do anything.
5. Brandon Hantz - this guy had some serious demons. If it were not for his famous uncle Russel not sure he would have ever been cast for the show. Says a lot when you are so toxic that your tribe intentionally forfeits a challenge just to vote you out then doesn't even want to go to tribal and just unanimously votes him out after a tirade.
6. Coach - some may say he was likable, I found the whole "Dragon Slayer" stuff quite annoying. I do think he is a good guy but his place on this list has to do with his annoying antics more than anything.
7. Shantel "Shan" - From season 41, she tried so hard to play a villain and was quite annoying while doing it. That season was so bad too after season 40 was so good.
8. NaOnka - another person that lacked some decency. Had an obsession with Kelly's prosthetic leg and kept targeting her because of it. Ironically she wound up quitting with 11 days left that season.
9. Sai - she's more recent so I had to keep that in mind when coming up with my list as compared to everyone above I don't thing she ranks up there with some of the lack of decency as a human being. Yes she was annoying and played too hard too early then was a drama queen when things did not go her way but I don't doubt her character like most of the people above on the list.
10. Michael Skupin - This one I really have to think about, could make the argument he belongs higher on the list too. The first season he played he fell into the fire and had to be medically evacuated. The 2nd time he played he made it to final tribal. He probably gets more bad attention for what happened outside of survivor as he was convicted for fraud and a child sex offender but he wasn't exactly well liked the 2nd time he played either.
Elephant in the room: Russel Hantz. I'm sure many would put him on their top 10 but for me he was one of the best "old school" players that never won the game. Found his way to the final tribal twice but his deceptive ways never got him the jury votes to win as he burned too many bridges with the jury to get there. He was entertaining which is why he doesn't make this list for me.
Damn good list right there!
Shan had two strikes, IMO. She claimed to be a pastor but cheerfully threw away her morals...and that freaking humming thing she did was SO artificial!
I have a particular dislike for Heidi and Parvati. I think it's mostly a particular type of woman thing for me, but the conceit and the way they used their bodies was distasteful to me. I'm not jealous; even when I had a decent body it wasn't my style to use it for my own gain. Don't @ me - I'm not as easily swayed by boobs as some of y'all!
Shan had two strikes, IMO. She claimed to be a pastor but cheerfully threw away her morals...and that freaking humming thing she did was SO artificial!
I have a particular dislike for Heidi and Parvati. I think it's mostly a particular type of woman thing for me, but the conceit and the way they used their bodies was distasteful to me. I'm not jealous; even when I had a decent body it wasn't my style to use it for my own gain. Don't @ me - I'm not as easily swayed by boobs as some of y'all!
Damn good list right there!
Shan had two strikes, IMO. She claimed to be a pastor but cheerfully threw away her morals...and that freaking humming thing she did was SO artificial!
I have a particular dislike for Heidi and Parvati. I think it's mostly a particular type of woman thing for me, but the conceit and the way they used their bodies was distasteful to me. I'm not jealous; even when I had a decent body it wasn't my style to use it for my own gain. Don't @ me - I'm not as easily swayed by boobs as some of y'all!
A perfect example of how Survivor has changed a lot over they years. The early years the females using their looks land flirting to advance their game was a pretty common thing and now you rarely see it. There were several seasons that seemed like someone would hook up and make out at night or something. Survivor Amazon was a prime example how the guys were more interested about hooking up with the females than playing the game. Trying to find the clip but not sure if it was that season or another where even at the tribal council the guys were even talking about the females on the other tribe. Was a phase where you kind of wondered are you playing Survivor to win or playing to hook up with someone as they already have a show called Big Brother that might be more suited for that goal.
Hated Rob and Amber. Hated Shan and Sai. I have not seen all the seasons, so there are others that would disgust me, I'm sure.
I did like Russell.... that dude played hard.
I did like Russell.... that dude played hard.
Been watching this season yep it was first time guys went to tribal.
Spousal unit despises Rob. His favorite quote (read with a BAHSton accent):
Ah got a haht on mah ahm for ahmbuh...
Yeah he probably should be on the list now that I think of it
The entire cast of season 5. I'm pretty sure that's the one where the sleazy used car salesman won because the other guy was even worse. Also had the drama of a married man humping a married woman "because he was sleeping and thought she was his wife."
What about the dude that they had to kick off for Harrassing females. Can't remember his name. He kept rubbing their shoulders and they would basically hide from him. The final straw was him doing something to a crew member. Dude was a perv. Richard hatch when he came back basically assaulted Sue. So lot of bad people on the show.
Dan was the guy who got kicked, he's been mentioned.
Several people hurt themselves coming back for more seasons. Hatch was weird the first season but was really the only person who had any type of strategy making him somewhat likable. I remember Jeff Varner being likable his first season but then came back and was an awful human. Ozzy was good early but then kept playing more and more stupid and acted entitled like people owed him something for being on the show. Rupert was a larger than life character when he first came to the show but rode his honest loyal persona to exhaustion. It's almost like these people let the fame of the "character" they were on this show go to their head and somehow felt Invincible.
Boston Rob grew on me. At first I hated him but eventually grew to root for him. Maybe I subconsciously thought if he wins he'll stop showing up.
Yeah I was a huge Rupert fan that first season. Ozzie never figured out that you can't be that good at challenges and win. He just kept playing the same game with no switch. It's weird that some of the returning players just kept playing the same game that made them lose the first time around.
That was Dan who is #3 on my list. Richard Hatch is a complicated one because the nudity thing was mostly a tactic to scare people from engaging in contact with him. The early seasons there were a lot more physical challenges where you had to go head to head with someone and he came up with this idea if he had his junk out no one would want to come near him. Not trying to downplay the incident with Sue but there was a lot of discussion/controversy about what his intent was. Personally, I didn't really care for him regardless but at the time he played no one had tried the nude thing as a strategy.
Like #10 on my list Hatch probably developed more of a negative reputation after the show more than he did while he appeared on the show. He was convicted of a domestic assault on his partner then served time in prison for tax evasion too. There is a video out there of him explaining he was originally invited to play for season 40 but some of the social issues that happened in the season before they filmed 40 the producers decided he would not be part of the cast.
Looks like Brandon H is going/has gone to prison for arson/racketeering.
I don't think Sai-onarra was nearly as bad as some of these mentioned, but I was happy to see her sent home. Y'all have an amazing memory as I had to google most these people and i've watched every season!
I don't think Sai-onarra was nearly as bad as some of these mentioned, but I was happy to see her sent home. Y'all have an amazing memory as I had to google most these people and i've watched every season!
