Linebacker Injury Status?

TornadoBird

Member
Aug 22, 2024
24
37
13
It sure doesn't sound like any of the main LBs will be back. I think it was a positive that Cael was back for a bit on Saturday and another week to heal would be a good thing.
Was Bacon still on crutches on Saturday? If he's been off his leg for 6 weeks now I think it's fair to assume Campbell's been downplaying a season ending injury. Additionally, despite all the downplaying of the Brahmer situation -- I won't be convinced that he also isn't dealing with a long-term injury. Crutches and a full leg immobilizing brace doesn't get handed out for just a "tweak". I'd love to see them both contribute, but not sure either of them at 75% is better than their respective back ups.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: amishclone

Eclecticlone

Member
Feb 21, 2019
32
-6
8
SEI
Was Bacon still on crutches on Saturday? If he's been off his leg for 6 weeks now I think it's fair to assume Campbell's been downplaying a season ending injury. Additionally, despite all the downplaying of the Brahmer situation -- I won't be convinced that he also isn't dealing with a long-term injury. Crutches and a full leg immobilizing brace doesn't get handed out for just a "tweak". I'd love to see them both contribute, but not sure either of them at 75% is better than their respective back ups.
does anyone have the video of Bacon's injury?

6 weeks in a brace and crutches could be a fibular fracture + tightrope or a meniscal repair, the two most likely with "lower leg injury" has me leaning towards fibular fracture + tightrope.

Straight leg brace and crutches absolutely could be a tweak. Non operative LCL and MCL would be a straight leg brace, would be a brace for pain and stability while they wait on an MRI.
 

Aclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2007
26,819
23,275
113
Des Moines, Ia.
Was Bacon still on crutches on Saturday? If he's been off his leg for 6 weeks now I think it's fair to assume Campbell's been downplaying a season ending injury. Additionally, despite all the downplaying of the Brahmer situation -- I won't be convinced that he also isn't dealing with a long-term injury. Crutches and a full leg immobilizing brace doesn't get handed out for just a "tweak". I'd love to see them both contribute, but not sure either of them at 75% is better than their respective back ups.
How is CMC saying that Caleb is out for the season “downplaying” it?

It’s McLaughlin he said might be back before the end of the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheCaptain

cycloneman003

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 14, 2008
5,045
4,042
113
Madison, WI
How is CMC saying that Caleb is out for the season “downplaying” it?

It’s McLaughlin he said might be back before the end of the season.
Somehow people keep saying that he’s definitely out for the season when immediately after the injury Campbell said he could return later in the season.

Doesn’t mean he will, but he definitely said Bacon could potentially make his way back. Personally I’d think regular season is out of the question, but perhaps Big 12 championship game or beyond time timeframe.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5745.jpeg
    IMG_5745.jpeg
    1 MB · Views: 37

cyclone87

Well-Known Member
Apr 6, 2011
3,315
1,538
113
Ames, IA
What was McLaughlin’s injury exactly? Also I thought Barnes did pretty well, close to the top in terms of number of tackles again and I believe a couple of those were for a loss.
 
Last edited:

isufbcurt

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2006
27,484
44,396
113
46
Newton
They must really like Barnes at Mike because they had Brezina playing a lot of SAM (instead of Mike) when he was in.

I just thought that was add because Brezina was doing really well at Mike before his injury.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: bozclone

isucy86

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
9,115
7,721
113
Dubuque
Also the running teams that we are facing all have fast running QBs. I would rather have a chance of a LB trying to beat a quick QB to the edge than an additional Dlineman.

I flip flop on ISU being a 3-3-5 team all the time. It's hard to argue with Heacock's results over his tenure at ISU. When he was at Toledo they did play a 4-2-5, so he should have a good grasp if it could benefit ISU, if even as an alternative.

The 3-3-5 has been a very effective pass & run defense. It's hard to argue the terrific pass defense results so far:
  • 3rd nationally in YPA
  • 7th in YPC
  • 3rd in pass completion %
  • 1st in Opponent Passer Rating

But at some point this season, I feel we will need to get pressure on a QB to win a game.
  • Rushing four 260lb+ DT/DE's would provide a more physical match-up against opposing OL's. If we had LB's who were great pass rushers, I might feel differently. But it seems like our LB's struggle to get sacks when they blitz. Through 7 games we only have 9 sacks (Singleton: 3, Snyder: 2 plus Petersen, Ezeogu Ebel, Klosterman at 1 each). The Clones currently rank 120+ in sack %.
  • IMO a 3 man rush creates pretty big windows for a QB to scan the secondary. And it creates big lanes for a scrambling QB. Bringing 4 big lineman could obstuct a QB's vision and force a scrambling QB to go wide where LB's and DB's can support.
 

CycloneSpinning

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2022
1,044
1,347
113
44
They must really like Barnes at Mike because they had Brezina playing a lot of SAM (instead of Mike) when he was in.

I just thought that was add because Brezina was doing really well at Mike before his injury.
You would know better than most…things I wouldn’t even think of…but is it possible it’s that Barnes isn’t great in coverage against the tight end?
 

Cyclad

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
3,008
3,726
113
Was Bacon still on crutches on Saturday? If he's been off his leg for 6 weeks now I think it's fair to assume Campbell's been downplaying a season ending injury. Additionally, despite all the downplaying of the Brahmer situation -- I won't be convinced that he also isn't dealing with a long-term injury. Crutches and a full leg immobilizing brace doesn't get handed out for just a "tweak". I'd love to see them both contribute, but not sure either of them at 75% is better than their respective back ups.
I sat next to Brahmers dad and grandfather on Saturday. They said it is an MCL injury, severity unknown at the time.
 

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,551
63,601
113
Not exactly sure.
You would know better than most…things I wouldn’t even think of…but is it possible it’s that Barnes isn’t great in coverage against the tight end?
I think Cael’s more athletic and they feel better with his speed and knowledge of the position to put him out there. The Mike can generally focus on the run in our defense and doesn’t deal with as much pass coverage.

Heacock has done a great job. At first I figured that LB was the last position we could take losses at. The more I thought about it, it’s probably the best position for us to get injured. It’s was/is our weakest position at the start of the year. When you have an average group, the drop off isnt as large as when you replace a group as good as our secondary with 3 rd stringers. Our Dline and secondary are still fairly intact so that allows them to carry the LBers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CycloneSpinning

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,551
63,601
113
Not exactly sure.
I sat next to Brahmers dad and grandfather on Saturday. They said it is an MCL injury, severity unknown at the time.
I guess that’s better than an ACL. Isn’t that like 6 weeks? Pending the severity of it. If a strain, then maybe a few weeks less?
 

Aclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2007
26,819
23,275
113
Des Moines, Ia.
Somehow people keep saying that he’s definitely out for the season when immediately after the injury Campbell said he could return later in the season.

Doesn’t mean he will, but he definitely said Bacon could potentially make his way back. Personally I’d think regular season is out of the question, but perhaps Big 12 championship game or beyond time timeframe.
I literally listened to Campbell say he was out for the season, several days after the injury.
 

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,455
25,846
113
Somehow people keep saying that he’s definitely out for the season when immediately after the injury Campbell said he could return later in the season.

Doesn’t mean he will, but he definitely said Bacon could potentially make his way back. Personally I’d think regular season is out of the question, but perhaps Big 12 championship game or beyond time timeframe.

It's best to just assume anyone with an injury is out for the season and be pleasantly surprised if they return.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spanky

Eclecticlone

Member
Feb 21, 2019
32
-6
8
SEI
I sat next to Brahmers dad and grandfather on Saturday. They said it is an MCL injury, severity unknown at the time.
Grade 2, partial MCL would usually be a straight leg brace for 4-6 weeks, then full return. However, if its a grade 1, just a stretch, not a tear, could be back in 4 weeks or less.