We've been to 3 bowl games. (Liberty, Alamo and Camping World) By far our least favorite was being in Orlando. Nothing but a bunch of 'meh'. Memphis and San Antonio seem to embrace their games, Orlando doesn't care.
Insight/Fiesta is a wonderful time. Anyone who went to Insight in 2001 or 2009 knows the city "embraces" the bowl. Was sad 2020 Fiesta was during Covid and they didn't allow fans.
My best to worst ISU bowl places I have been to:
1. Alamo Bowl - SA, TX
2. Insight/Fiesta - PHX area, AZ
3. Cheez It/Camping/Pop Tart - Orlando, FL
4. Liberty Bowl - Memphis, TN
5. Houston Bowl - Houston, TX
6. Independence Bowl - Shreveport, LS
7. Pinstripe Bowl - NYC, NY
8. Potato Bowl - Boise, ID
7 & 8 I would never attend again. San Antonio, PHX, or Houston would all be my preferred places to revisit. Orlando & Memphis I've done twice now in recent memory so I'd rather go to Texas or Arizona again first.