- Mar 27, 2006
- 43,012
- 34,521
- 113
Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall
Humpty Dumpty had a great fall
All the King's horses
And all the King's men
Couldn't put Humpty together again.
Who was this guy? He must have been really important, because the King sends the ENTIRE ARMY to try to save one guy. That's the equivalent of calling in the 101st Airborne to rescue a pet cat out of a tree. Unless it's a really special cat, it's a significant overreaction.
And why exactly are the horses there? I realize that this particular nursery rhyme was written a long time ago. Were horses considered essential to the practice of medicine, in the past? Like "We can't do this amputation until the surgical horse is sanitized."? I get that it's an All Hands On Deck event, but aside from transportation to the site of the accident, what's Mr. Ed bringing to the table?
Also, why is Humpty Dumpty always depicted as an egg? That's nowhere in the rhyme. Where are we getting "egg" out of that? There's nothing more to the story, as far as I know. No second verse saying:
Humpty Dumpty pleaded and begged
Humpty screamed while they stitched up his leg
But all of their efforts
And all of their vomit
Couldn't keep Humpty from becoming an omelette.
Not to mention that this tale of death and dismemberment and failed animal medical practices is intended for kids.
Humpty Dumpty had a great fall
All the King's horses
And all the King's men
Couldn't put Humpty together again.
Who was this guy? He must have been really important, because the King sends the ENTIRE ARMY to try to save one guy. That's the equivalent of calling in the 101st Airborne to rescue a pet cat out of a tree. Unless it's a really special cat, it's a significant overreaction.
And why exactly are the horses there? I realize that this particular nursery rhyme was written a long time ago. Were horses considered essential to the practice of medicine, in the past? Like "We can't do this amputation until the surgical horse is sanitized."? I get that it's an All Hands On Deck event, but aside from transportation to the site of the accident, what's Mr. Ed bringing to the table?
Also, why is Humpty Dumpty always depicted as an egg? That's nowhere in the rhyme. Where are we getting "egg" out of that? There's nothing more to the story, as far as I know. No second verse saying:
Humpty Dumpty pleaded and begged
Humpty screamed while they stitched up his leg
But all of their efforts
And all of their vomit
Couldn't keep Humpty from becoming an omelette.
Not to mention that this tale of death and dismemberment and failed animal medical practices is intended for kids.
Last edited:

