I would be willing to bet that older critics lean towards the 'it's great' side of things with the younger critics really not liking it. Spielberg just doesn't and hasn't resonated with young movie goers in a very long time unfortunately. But for those that grew up on his stuff...this is a great addition to his movie cannon. I think it's a great side piece to Close Encounters with a nice dose of Minority Report. If you like those movies, you'll like this one very much.
