Most of these predictions are not worth very much, although not quite as bad as most of the so-called bracketologists for the NCAA MBB tournament.
Here is the report of a little research I did in 2017 about the quality of predictions. Sorry, I haven't done it for the last two years, but I probably will do it again this year.
Dec 3, 2017
Have you ever wondered which of the guys predicting bowl assignments performed best? Well, I double-checked the picks of 6 prominent sports media guys.
Here are the results based on 1 point for picking one team in a bowl and 3 points for picking both teams (total correct picks in parenthesis with 78 possible). A perfect set of predictions would yield 117 points.
Jason Kirk (SB Nation). 58 points. Picked both teams for 14 bowls and one for 16 bowls (54 picks).
Erick Smith (USA Today). 55 points. Picked both teams for 12 bowls and one for 19 bowls (41 picks).
David Hale (ESPN). 53 points. Picked both teams for 11 bowls and one for 20 bowls (42 picks).
Kyle Bongura (ESPN). 45 points. Picked both teams for 10 bowls and one for 15 bowls (35 picks).
Jerry Palm (CBS). 42 points. Picked both teams for 9 bowls and one for 15 bowls (33 picks).
Eric Single (SI). 35 points. Picked both teams for 5 bowls and one for 20 bowls (30 picks).
Looks like I may have come up with a new game. Maybe next year, I will start a thread for a pool in which we can have a contest for our picks of bowl assignments.