I don't make the playoffs in my league if I take Calvin Johnson instead of Manning. Now, I almost lost the last two weeks because Manning has been sucking and was hurt, but that's beside the point. I guess I'm coming from late first round where there are no RBs left and the elite WRs have been taken.
Well Calvin obviously had his problems this year. WRs getting injured that badly is more rare than an RB getting injured or replaced, which I think we agree on.
I think there are probably a handful of WRs that would have served you better than Peyton if you took them in the late first.
Dez
Brown
Alshon Jeffrey
DT
Jordy
Cobb
Julio
All those guys were going pick 5/6 or later and I'd rather have them than Manning personally. And out of the top WRs the only ones I can think of that had injury issues were Green and Calvin off the top of my head.