Maybe it was, but most people HATED his offenses for the majority of his first stint here at Iowa State. But yet fans seem to have forgotten that and are now clamoring for him to come back and head coach us - I don't think so.
You are right, those offences with the Davis Brother's really sucked! ...and it didn't get much better with Sage & Seneca (Jr Year) at QB. Let's move on!
First, I didn't realize Loney was instrumental in the Davis' brothers decision to come to Iowa State - silly me...
Second, just how much coaching "genius" does it take to give the best RB in the land the ball and to tell him to run forward with it? My guess is I could have made a couple hundred gr a year doing that and I would be viewed as "quite successful" by many on this board.
Third, the fact that the Davis brothers were as great as they were here in spite of questionable offensive lines and the defense stacking the box because we weren't a credible threat to pass is more credit to the Davis brothers' abilities more than it was Loney's abilities to coach.
Fourth, as great as the Davis brothers were here at ISU, just how much of an impact did those offenses have at winning games? Based on the stats, we averaged 19.4 points per game in 1997, 20.1 points per game in 1998, and 22.5 points per game in 1999. For comparison's sake, this team averaged 25.3 points per game this year, and most people on this site would consider McFarland a less than average offensive coordinator.
Fifth, yes, the offense looked great the first half of 2002 when Seneca Wallace & co. ran all over those teams. Then we ran into the teeth of the schedule, playing "real" defenses that knew exactly what play was going to be called before it came into the sidelines, basically rendering Wallace & Co. useless the second half of the season
Sixth, the whole thing of Loney leaving Iowa State twice using the excuse of "broadening the resume" or "I'll never get a chance here" to me more screams of Chizik's line "I left here a couple of years ago so I would be able to come back home at a later date."
But yeah, despite all these things, Loney would be a GREAT hire for head coach here at Iowa State... :no:
