Star Wars Expanded Universe Thread

Bret44

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 8, 2009
17,303
7,889
113
Cedar River Valley
Anyone seen a list of theaters that will be playing Return of the Jedi for the 40th Anniversary release? I have used the google machine and am coming up empty.
 

bos

Legend
Staff member
Apr 10, 2006
30,629
6,415
113
Anyone seen a list of theaters that will be playing Return of the Jedi for the 40th Anniversary release? I have used the google machine and am coming up empty.
Which version. The CGI weird one or the original?
 

BryceC

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 23, 2006
26,462
19,624
113
I believe Lucasfilm basically destroyed all of the old Greedo shot first footage.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,694
66,045
113
LA LA Land
I believe Lucasfilm basically destroyed all of the old Greedo shot first footage.

sadly there is only one version. the version disney/lucasfilms wants out.

My old avatar was a laserdisc and what got me started down that path in the early 00s was the best commercial media release of the theatrical cut. (before amazing bluray bootlegs existed that in part used footage captured from from elite rare LD players). I actually had Phantom Menace from Japan on laserdisc too just because I think it's funny laserdisc still existed in Japan then. I sold that one years back.

71-BgeEJkaL._AC_UF894,1000_QL80_.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: bos

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,694
66,045
113
LA LA Land
One of the few DVDs I will hold on to forever are my Star Wars Special Editions where they had the late-90s remaster on the first disc but on the Special Features disc you can see the un-altered version of the movie.

I used to be so into this stuff and now the memory gets hazy...but even on those I seem to remember the AV nerds being upset that they weren't anamorphic or something else about the quality was substandard even for DVDs of the time.

It's just crazy to me they don't keep them going as a dual thing. I mean the theatrical versions are cinema history and they could always sell both or use both as a way to pimp their subscription service.
 

houjix

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2021
1,916
1,918
113
One of the few DVDs I will hold on to forever are my Star Wars Special Editions where they had the late-90s remaster on the first disc but on the Special Features disc you can see the un-altered version of the movie.
I have those too. I think I even have the pre-SE VHS copies somewhere.

You know, I liked some of the original Special Editions updates. The graphical cleanups were nice and making Cloud City look more open was cool. The Greedo now shooting was stupid, but whatever. However adding "Jedi Rocks" to RotJ was where I just about lost it.
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
Reactions: 3GenClone and HFCS

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,694
66,045
113
LA LA Land
I picked up this set some years back. Got a free player way back and these are the only LDs I own.
laserdisc+007.JPG

Even though those are the oldest widescreen releases, I find the picture quality to actually be my favorite. The sound is supposedly not as good pre THX but I'm no audiophile and they all sound identical to me. Plus coolest cover art.

The big box set I keep just as a collector but it's the CAV 30 minute per side format that has incredible forward/pause/reverse that not streaming and 4k could never do but after the original wow factor I never use it and not worth the disc flipping.

If I actually watch them it's this set or the faces set.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,694
66,045
113
LA LA Land
I have those too. I think I even have the pre-SE VHS copies somewhere.

You know, I liked some of the original Special Editions updates. The graphical cleanups were nice and making Cloud City look more open was cool. The Greedo now shooting was stupid, but whatever. However adding "Jedi Rocks" to RotJ was where I just about lost it.

Agree it's a mixed bag. I could have selected half the changes and just rolled with it. The other thing is the digital effects in LOTR just a few years later made most of it look far more dated than the original traditional effects. Original band looks way more real than the new fake band, then the fake band goes and breaks the 4th wall visually.

Cloud city is the most objective "improvement", even as a kid in the late 80s with my VHS copies I thought Cloud City was the part of where I could tell a lot of it was paintings and small sets. ROTJ really didn't need any edits, it's one of the most perfect traditional effects movies of all time. ROTJ should have just been a modern film restoration no different than Lawrence of Arabia or something. The Jabba scene should have just been left in the extras without the CG Jabba.
 

houjix

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2021
1,916
1,918
113
Agree it's a mixed bag. I could have selected half the changes and just rolled with it. The other thing is the digital effects in LOTR just a few years later made most of it look far more dated than the original traditional effects. Original band looks way more real than the new fake band, then the fake band goes and breaks the 4th wall visually.

Cloud city is the most objective "improvement", even as a kid in the late 80s with my VHS copies I thought Cloud City was the part of where I could tell a lot of it was paintings and small sets. ROTJ really didn't need any edits, it's one of the most perfect traditional effects movies of all time. ROTJ should have just been a modern film restoration no different than Lawrence of Arabia or something. The Jabba scene should have just been left in the extras without the CG Jabba.
Outside of the the matte painting of the Falcon in the background of the prep scene right before heading off to Endor, there is almost nothing in RotJ I would have even touched beyond cleaning up any fuzziness. The effects still look good compared to a lot of things today.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: bos and HFCS

bos

Legend
Staff member
Apr 10, 2006
30,629
6,415
113
Even though those are the oldest widescreen releases, I find the picture quality to actually be my favorite. The sound is supposedly not as good pre THX but I'm no audiophile and they all sound identical to me. Plus coolest cover art.

The big box set I keep just as a collector but it's the CAV 30 minute per side format that has incredible forward/pause/reverse that not streaming and 4k could never do but after the original wow factor I never use it and not worth the disc flipping.

If I actually watch them it's this set or the faces set.
It’s funny how the older tech still brings so much joy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HFCS

jdcyclone19

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2017
3,548
4,876
113
Iowa
With the recently announced New Jedi Order movie, there's always a chance he comes back there, assuming he survives past the Mando-verse stuff.


The episode was called Spies. They've been pretty intentional on their word choices this season in the titles. That would indicate more than one.

As far as the possible Mando spy, three possible candidates: Axe Wolves, The Armorer, or the surface survivors.

The similarity of The Armorer's and Gideon's armor, her abrupt change in attitude toward Bo on Nevarro and now being gung ho to get them to go to Mandalore, and taking off before the battle makes her suspicious.

Axe Wolves going to get "help" during the battle makes little sense as who was he going to get help from? The only ship they landed with (one of those dumb tactical points things that I previously mentioned) left the surface and you supposedly cannot contact space from the ground. Plus pretty sure all of the away team was already there. Still probably hates Bo after losing command, but not sure when he had time before this to get on Gideon's payroll.

The survivors conveniently know about the forge, but not the secret Imperial base just 10 feet away? Seems suspect They are easiest to believe, but nothing they did outside of bringing the away team to the forge faster really screams spies. Then again, they level of subtlety of this series is sometimes lacking.

I think it’s Axe. They found beskar on the ship Gideon was broken out of. So there’s gotta be some mandalorian working with him.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: SCNCY

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron