Should Paul Rhoads be fired?

Should Paul Rhoads be fired?


  • Total voters
    321
I'd love to track down his extension from after the 2011 season and see what the buyout would be right now. He's signed through the 2021 season right now, I believe.

Buyout is $750,000 a year or around $3.5 mil. Rest of staff thankfully is in last years of contract so won't spend money there. It's possible too they negotiate a lesser amount for cpr. Possible. Biggest problem is we woild need a huge booster to step up and fire cpr likely and our two largest boosters think of CPr as family.
 
A lot of people keep asking for Mangino. If you think MM would Do better, is it because you believe he is being hand cuffed as the OC by CPR?

I believe there is likely something to this but no, nothing is salvageable at this point.
 
It's funny to think back to the "out of gas" threads from a few years ago, the writing was on the wall, we hit a recruiting lull 2/3 years ago and the lack of talent from those classes is emerging. When you look at at team like Iowa, they don't recruit amazing talent, they don't get much better players than we do but thye difference is they get the players they target. We have been scrapping together classes in February (and beyond), taking 3rd and 4th choices, basically getting our pick of the leftovers.
 
Mangino doesn't deserve an audition, the offense is the worst part of this team. If we are firing Rhoads then Mangino should not be the full-time replacement; the staff needs a complete and wholesale cleaning out. Start fresh

A lot of people keep asking for Mangino. If you think MM would Do better, is it because you believe he is being hand cuffed as the OC by CPR?

You are not going to hire a new coach mid season, and we know CPR is not going to get this done. Give Mangino the keys and see if he can have a miraculous turn around. I'm sure he can't, and we will end up looking else where at seasons end, but we can at least see if he is the right fit. What's to lose at this point?
 
Upgraded facilities and our fan base have to be attractive to the right person. I vote Mangino.

MM is part of the problem...our offense under him has been worse....worse folks. For a guy with as much Oline and OC experience and Isu having a veteran oline things should be much better but they are worse since he took over.

As for having him as an interim coach well eithe wsy u can kiss the 2016 class goodbye. No recruit is coming to Isu if they don't know who cosch will be. Plus will be attrition as well. I'm all for firing cpr, I wasnt before but am now, but realize we won't do a thing until at least 2018.
 
A lot of people keep asking for Mangino. If you think MM would Do better, is it because you believe he is being hand cuffed as the OC by CPR?
I got roasted just a few short days ago for asking this same question. I honestly don't know if thats the case but its one of the few reasons I could get behind a midseason firing rather than just waiting until the end of the year.
 
To play devil's advocate we are a kick and 4 minutes away from 3-0 and threads saying how the turnaround has started.

This is bs. I'm tired of hearing this. I've been saying this to my hawk buddies for years and it's bs. There is a fine line between winning and losing a lot of times and Isu is always...always on the other side. Why? The HC. Teams with great leaders who now how to put their team in the right position to make the plays to win almost always are on the right side of winning. CPR is not one of those.
 
What's really too bad is I think Ayeni and Lindquist are really good up and coming coaches who are also our best recruiters. Eggen too. But outside of that the rest are awful.
 
"I don't hire great people to tell them what to do. I hire great people so they can tell me what to do."-- Steve Jobs

so why does Paul think he needs to make calls on O!? He hired Mangino to run the offense, let him. He called a to when the O was rolling and Mangino about lost it! He was in the offensive huddle multiple times making comments and Mangino either shook his head or ignored him. Let your coaches, coach!
 
In regards to Mangino succeeding at ISU, he is a better HC than OC. The question was could he add that superior HC ability from the OC position. It was always doubtful.
 
Last edited:
Chizik was unquestionably the better coach and left us in a far better spot than Rhoads is going to. We at least had some talent on the roster when he left.

The talent on the field wasn't the problem last night. There are factors outside a coach's control, but some ha can definitely control. Penalties - Penalties are a reflection of coaching, Bill Snyder's teams go nearly a season with fewer penalties than we had last night. Injuries - Any particular player can go down any time, but we seem to continually have a lineup held together with duct tape and knee braces. Game coaching - the only time the offense played with any tempo was when we were down 10. The rest of the time, we were out there killing time and hoping not to lose. And 7 points is more than three points. We should go for touchdowns. CPR's first couple of years, we were one of the best in the country at Red Zone efficiency. Now we play for field goals. I have confidence in the assistants, just not the head coach.
 
This is bs. I'm tired of hearing this. I've been saying this to my hawk buddies for years and it's bs. There is a fine line between winning and losing a lot of times and Isu is always...always on the other side. Why? The HC. Teams with great leaders who now how to put their team in the right position to make the plays to win almost always are on the right side of winning. CPR is not one of those.

If Toledo had some receivers who could hang on to the ball, we might have lost by 20.
 
I can name you programs that can and do win that will fire their coach if they lose to this bunch. If we somehow ambush some team when we get 9 turnovers or influenza breaks out in the opposing teams locker room or such...that coach will be fired for losing to CPR. I do think Texas's talent and the fact that our team will long since given up will lead to a 45 point woodshedding whenwe play them....but say something crazy happens, like Rhoads actually takes the money and resigns. The team rallys and plays their buts off and some competent offensive coaching gives us a win. I assure you, Strong will be met at the Des Moines airport and be given a bus ticket to the city that is not Austin of his choice. Stoops might get fired too if he lost to us this year.
 
I don't think you fire him before end of the season. I'd still give him the chance to get to 5 wins minimum to consider retaining him. Don't see it happening, but what good is completely dumping the season at this point? If you dump him now it also gives players more time to think about transferring. There's still enough talent on this team that you don't want a mass exodus.
How much is Paul adding to the team at this point?
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron