I work customer facing of a big tech company and my anecdotal evidence is that all the grads from the “smart” schools like Stanford, MIT, Cornell etc all flame out in a year. They can’t handle talking with customers and especially frustrated customers. People who went to State schools, especially Southern or Midwest ones like Illinois, Alabama, Georgia, ISU etc really excel.I understand the value of rankings, open doors, and perception of academics for universities obviously. It’s kind of a pet peeve for me though.
This is completely anecdotal. But, my company is based in SF and as we were accelerating our growth/hiring in 2016 we added a lot of Stanford/Cal grads as well as recent grads from other schools. The absolute rockstar on my team was from Penn State, a good school but still a state school). I, myself am an ISU grad, and I was having to hold the hands of a lot of Stanford and Cal grads, who all flamed out within a year. They absolutely could not handle the gig. It was then where I realized, the person is all that matters, not the school.
This doesn’t really have anything to do with realignment. But when I see posts about Georgia being so much better of a business school than Kansas, or the PAC 12 schools being light years ahead of B12 in academics, none of that means jack **** in the real world.
It’s unfortunate we’ve basically stopped recruiting at ISU due to the College of Engineering screwery with career fair stuff. We’ve basically opened a major pipeline with Alabama and Georgia instead and a ton of grads get hired from them.