I'll vote for slices.
But only four slices...
Ours will turn 14 a week before the first softball game. At this point she is their best option for varsity catcher (our school is severely lacking softball players, our "best" pitcher is also an 8th grader).
One of Ottumwa's ace softball pitchers was an "8th grader" last summer. (We really didn't have a #1/#2, more like #1a/#1b) She was also the starting point guard for GBB this year. Really good athlete...runs in the family. Both older sisters were star basketball players, with the oldest being Ottumwa's all-time leading scorer.