Greatest Cyclone Quarterback

Aclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2007
28,208
27,180
113
Des Moines, Ia.
I posted the basis for this in the Wright thread, but decided to offer it up for discussion in it’s own thread. I’ve been thinking this for a while, and this seems as good a time as any.

It’s been said that Brock Purdy is about to go down as the greatest quarterback in the history of Cyclone football.

Well, I don’t have much quibble about that. Matter of fact, I think that by many perameters, by various metrics, it’s already true. And I’ve seen the best quarterbacks of the modern era, from David Archer through Seneca, Todd, Sage, Bret, Austen, Sam and...Steele.

On the other hand, I think that the way things are going under Matt Campbell, it might be more accurate to say that Brock is the best quarterback in the history of Cyclone football thus far.

Call him a trail blazer.

And this a new era of Cyclone football.

Now, the guys who come afterwards are going to have better corps of receivers. Better stables of running backs. And better offensive lines—definitely better offensive lines! And all of those assets to benefit from for their whole careers—not just their senior seasons, as Brock is likely to enjoy.

Not to mention having even better defenses, to get the ball back more often.

So, the truth of the matter is, those guys will likely have more notoriety as recruits. There’ll be people who break Brock’s records. Shoot, there’ll likely be kids who may be even better quarterbacks than Brock is—imagine Brock Purdy’s brain in Steele Jantz’s body.

(That would be a young John Elway, in case you’re wondering)

But just as Seneca will always be Seneca, Brock will always be Brock. Genuine and authentic.

Enjoy it at your nearest Jack Trice Stadium while you can.

Go Cyclones!
 
Last edited:
No question the best ISU QB ever was Seneca IMO.

Next up for me would be Sage.

Then probably Archer.

I can't comment fairly on Amundson because I never saw him play, but others can chime in on where they would put him. Just off of what I've heard, maybe Amundson would be right after Seneca, or after Sage?
 
How high on the list is Jacob Park?
I don’t think he’s even on the list—but when I looked through the record book, I was kinda surprised to see how high Park’s name was on some of the single game marks. High enough to be there for a while.
 
Statistically it will be Purdy.

I don't go any farther back the Sage so: Its Purdy, Seneca, and Sage as the best ever for me.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Cycho1
Gotta come up with some criteria first. If we're just going by stats, Brock will win this in a landslide. The people who've said Sage are basis that on his pro career because his college career was good but not great.

And comparing players like Amudson across eras is very difficult to do.

Really it comes down to Wins. Does he lead the team to victory while performing at an all conference rate?
 
I don’t disagree with the OP, but if you look back a bit (and understand the game was very different) George Amundson was one to consider.

My top five would be:
1) Brock Purdy
2) George Amundson
3) Seneca Wallace
4) Sage Rosenfels
5) Buddy Hardeman
 
  • Like
Reactions: t-noah