Sad news - Kill is a great coach and that's a big loss for Minnesota. Thoughts and prayers to him and his family!
In considering possibly competing against MN for a coach & taking off the rose color glasses, I really wonder which job would be more attractive to potential coaching candidates.
MN has a nicer stadium (though we significantly closed that gap), a little easier recruiting opportunities (if they could convince MN kids to stay home). Overall, MN has had more success than ISU, historically, but don't think that's a significant difference at this point. MN is the only P5 team in the state.
ISU has nicer facilities overall, plays in the Big XII (I think that's a slight edge, but conference stability might make that neutral). ISU has much better fan support and doesn't compete locally against pro teams for "attention" (MN struggles filling a 50K seat stadium). I think ISU has a better and more supportive Athletic Department and overall University Administration.
Again - I personally can't think of a reason a coach would want to go to MN, but trying to look at it objectively, it seems like a pretty level playing field.
What other considerations did I miss?
ISU