Christmas Movies

What is your favorite Christmas movie?


  • Total voters
    119
I love Christmas Vacation, although it's not the best Vacation movie, but my favorite Christmas movie will always be A Christmas Story.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Tailg8er
Haha, I can take a quote out of IAWL that's not Christmassy too. There are plenty of quotes in CV that are more Christmassy than pretty much anything cousin Eddie says...

;)

I was mostly trying to use one of the most famous quotes from CV. The most famous quote from IAWL has to be, "Every time a bell rings, an angel gets its wings." That's just a different sort of experience.

It's not to say that I don't like funny Christmas movies. Like I said earlier, I think Scrooged is likely my favorite. There are some others that are comedies that are way up there. I just think they're more memorable/funnier, and have better stories.
 
I'm curious as to what you voted as your favorite Christmas movie.

I voted for A Christmas Story, but that's mainly for Jean Shephard's voice. I'm not especially tied to it.

Honestly, in my family, the traditional Christmas movie we watch is actually another movie with Chevy Chase in it. We watch the Three Amigos when we get together. It was a tradition, growing up, when you opened up each one of your gifts, to loudly announce "IT'S A SWEATER!!" in a Mexican accent, ala El Guapo. That one's all about nostalgia for me.

And that's really my point. Nostalgia can make a movie into an all time great. That's what I think Christmas Vacation has going for it. If you don't have the nostalgia, you're left with a ho-hum, it's been done, comedy. There's nothing necessarily wrong with that, though.
 
I know, I just don't find it as hilarious as so many do. It's been years since I've seen it, but it was just not my favorite. I can't really pinpoint it, I just felt like it was sort of contrived, but not in a way that contributes to the story.

Like, to me, Airplane! or This Is Spinal Tap are two of the best comedies ever. Both are silly, and both are contrived - but the silliness is the point of the humor, and the jokes are more clever. I just don't get "clever" from Blues Brothers. I like clever, so I've had a hard time over the years with dumb comedies.

I've actually never seen Animal House!

I'm going to say it probably wouldn't be your favorite. It does have a lot of good scenes and I really liked it. Do NOT watch it with your kids until they are older. It definitely promotes drug and alcohol use. Belushi jumping the ladder along the sorority house, removing the horse from the Dean's office, going to the bar are all funny scenes though.

I think some of it is when a person grows up and what is funny/popular at that time, I was working with some people a bit younger than me when Jim Carrey was popular with the Pet detective movies and I never did appreciate them even though they thought they were hilarious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Angie
I voted for A Christmas Story, but that's mainly for Jean Shephard's voice. I'm not especially tied to it.

Honestly, in my family, the traditional Christmas movie we watch is actually another movie with Chevy Chase in it. We watch the Three Amigos when we get together. It was a tradition, growing up, when you opened up each one of your gifts, to loudly announce "IT'S A SWEATER!!" in a Mexican accent, ala El Guapo. That one's all about nostalgia for me.

And that's really my point. Nostalgia can make a movie into an all time great. That's what I think Christmas Vacation has going for it. If you don't have the nostalgia, you're left with a ho-hum, it's been done, comedy. There's nothing necessarily wrong with that, though.
Way way overrated. There really is nothing special about that movie. Way overplayed too. Also a bit racist at the end ;). I like how you copped out too by not really backing your choice.
 
I'm going to say it probably wouldn't be your favorite. It does have a lot of good scenes and I really liked it. Do NOT watch it with your kids until they are older. It definitely promotes drug and alcohol use. Belushi jumping the ladder along the sorority house, removing the horse from the Dean's office, going to the bar are all funny scenes though.

I think some of it is when a person grows up and what is funny/popular at that time, I was working with some people a bit younger than me when Jim Carrey was popular with the Pet detective movies and I never did appreciate them even though they thought they were hilarious.

I know that my dad, for example, LOVES Animal House, Blues Brothers, all of it. I never saw BB until I was at least 23 or so, so it wasn't a nostalgia thing for me, either. I'll have to give it a try either when the kids are asleep sometime, or later on.

Yeah, the Pet Detective movies were huge when I was in junior high/high school, but I was never a big fan of them because I just didn't feel like there was a whole lot clever there. On the other hand, I feel like Dumb & Dumber had a lot of clever moments in its very dumbness, so I like it much better than the other Carrey stuff.
 
Way way overrated. There really is nothing special about that movie. Way overplayed too. Also a bit racist at the end ;). I like how you copped out too by not really backing your choice.

Absolutely it's overrated and overplayed. Yep. No argument here. Of the given choices, it's the one I enjoy the best, but I'm under no illusion that it's a great movie. It isn't. The acting is pretty patchy. That's my point. Nostalgia works wonders.
 
I surprised no one has mentioned Miracle on 34th Street (the original) yet. Classic Christmas movie with the awesome court scene where the dump all of the Christmas letters on the judges desk to prove that Chris is Santa. Good stuff and needed to be on the list IMO.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CyInDFW and Angie
Jingle-All-The-Way-PS.jpg


And to anyone that doesn't think Die Hard is a Christmas movie, you don't understand the true meaning of Christmas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macloney
If Rudolph was classified as a movie, that would be it for me. Otherwise, I have to go with Scrooged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Angie
Christmas is not central to the plot of the movie, therefore, it's not a Christmas movie. If the movie took place during, say, Presidents' Day, the plot still holds (although the Santa hats and Christmas songs would be a little weird). If you moved, say, Christmas Vacation or A Christmas Story or It's a Wonderful Life or Elf or any other actual Christmas movie to, say, Presidents' Day, the plot doesn't hold up.

The only reason why a small, vocal minority names Die Hard as a Christmas movie is because this small, vocal, wrong minority doesn't like Christmas movies - or perhaps hates Christmas altogether.

So, Home Alone doesn't belong either?
 
Way way overrated. There really is nothing special about that movie. Way overplayed too. Also a bit racist at the end ;). I like how you copped out too by not really backing your choice.

The racist thing is the 3 Amigos part. Just ask Matt Campbell
vauEUgn.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: mapnerd
I know, I just don't find it as hilarious as so many do. It's been years since I've seen it, but it was just not my favorite. I can't really pinpoint it, I just felt like it was sort of contrived, but not in a way that contributes to the story.

Like, to me, Airplane! or This Is Spinal Tap are two of the best comedies ever. Both are silly, and both are contrived - but the silliness is the point of the humor, and the jokes are more clever. I just don't get "clever" from Blues Brothers. I like clever, so I've had a hard time over the years with dumb comedies.

I've actually never seen Animal House!

When you have an amp that goes to 11, you win.

You need to watch Animal House, if for no other reason, this:

 
  • Like
Reactions: Angie and arobb
So, Home Alone doesn't belong either?

For whatever reason I've never thought of Home Alone as a Christmas movie, either. I've never gone out of my way to watch it at Christmas (or any other time, in fact) in the last 20 years, which, come to think of it, is probably the last time I've actually watched it.
 
It's not Christmas for me until I've watched White Christmas and Holiday Inn.

Also, not sure on other people's opinion, but I consider Nightmare Before Christmas as more Christmas than Halloween, so I'd lump it in my group too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Angie