Blowout loss to Baylor, Rhoads fired?



You act like this is completely Pollard's decision. Its not. Leath and Donors will force JP to get rid of CPR.

There were quite a few people willing to give him another year with what we brought back last year, esp. on D. However, there is no excuse for this year. Support is gone, and a change will be forced.


Our AD doesn't have $5 mil laying around. That's what it will cost plus we will be hiring a new staff. Unless Leath wants to pony up and/or we have some donors to help then CPR will be back.
 
I believe there is a better chance of this if we get blown out in a week by Texas on homecoming...... Baylor this week, not so much, that is expected.....
 
Our AD doesn't have $5 mil laying around. That's what it will cost plus we will be hiring a new staff. Unless Leath wants to pony up and/or we have some donors to help then CPR will be back.

If 5000 season ticket holders don't renew a pair of tickets, even if they keep their donations the same, that adds up to $4.5 million, so do we lose that money in a buyout, or from season ticket sales? If I were in charge, I'd opt for the plan that moves the program forward.
 
Where did I say anything about Pollard?

The way he is coaching, just doesn't look like a coach who's concerned about his job. I'm the opposite of a Pollard hater, so my post had nothing to do with that.

Fair enough. I just see no way a change is no made/forced this off-season. Even if JP told CPR his job is fine, there is no way CPR and JP don't realize that a change may be forced from the top. Leath seems like a guy who likes thing to be run a certain way, and I find it impossible to believe he continues to be OK with support falling off.
 
Our AD doesn't have $5 mil laying around. That's what it will cost plus we will be hiring a new staff. Unless Leath wants to pony up and/or we have some donors to help then CPR will be back.

Of course our AD does not have that laying around, but like every other program in the Country, Donors will pay the buyout.
 
Fair enough. I just see no way a change is no made/forced this off-season. Even if JP told CPR his job is fine, there is no way CPR and JP don't realize that a change may be forced from the top. Leath seems like a guy who likes thing to be run a certain way, and I find it impossible to believe he continues to be OK with support falling off.

Yep. And when the donation came in for the SEZ, behind the scenes that tied the athletic department even tighter to the President's office. There's a reason they kept calling it "The front door to Iowa State University", and it wasn't because they were looking forward to wiping poo all over their front door and then inviting folks over for lunch.
 
Didn't know if I should make a new thread or just post this in the Baylor thread... But


If we do get blown up--- 70-10, 70-21, something along those lines, would Rhoads get the can or is he basically in there for the long haul of the season?

I think you make immediate firings for results that aren't predicted to occur. Not for ones that happen as everyone expects.
 
Yes. Impatience. If there is one thing that ISU is not, it's impatient with the football program as the fact that he is still coaching here this year attests.

Keeping him till the end of the season proves that ISU is fine with double digit loss seasons and that having one doesn't shorten the noose until the end of next year.

If you were to fire Rhoads mid-season, who would you elevate to head coach? Do you think any of the other in-house candidates would do anything to improve the situation? Can you separate their performance from Rhoads for the lack of on-the-field results to show there is basis to believe the team will get a few more wins?
 
If you were to fire Rhoads mid-season, who would you elevate to head coach? Do you think any of the other in-house candidates would do anything to improve the situation? Can you separate their performance from Rhoads for the lack of on-the-field results to show there is basis to believe the team will get a few more wins?

The only reason I am in favor of it is because if you wait until he end of the season, this entire staff is gone. What if Mangino is the answer? What if Mangino wins 4 of the last 5 games? We'll never know.

Worst thing that happens is we continue to lose, and the interim coach is let go at seasons end, which will be the same result if CPR stays.
 
If you were to fire Rhoads mid-season, who would you elevate to head coach? Do you think any of the other in-house candidates would do anything to improve the situation? Can you separate their performance from Rhoads for the lack of on-the-field results to show there is basis to believe the team will get a few more wins?
Even though I think he couldn't change that much, but maybe MM. Maybe even throw in Ayeni
 
I keep thinking that JP will keep CPR around next year but then I looked back at McCarney. I forgot that in Mac's last two years the team was 11-13. Looking back it seems like the team was so bad and everyone was calling for Mac's head. I can't imagine keeping a coach that is 4-20 over the last 2 years.

Can it seriously get any worse for this program?