Purdy never had an Oline this bad. The pass protection was generally pretty good.
It's been astonishing seeing how much more comfortable he is on a roll out or similar and how it's seldom used.
After some research, I've come around on Dekkers
- Thread starter Cyinthenorth
- Start date
Purdy never had an Oline this bad. The pass protection was generally pretty good.
It's been astonishing seeing how much more comfortable he is on a roll out or similar and how it's seldom used.
Oh he's not terrible, not at all. I think he's more than good enough to be the guy going forward. I just have been baffled a little bit by the whole season on offense, him included.
Here's the link to the passes per completion - as well as just overall NCAA stats.
www.ncaa.com
NCAA College Football FBS current individual Stats | NCAA.com
Discover the current NCAA FBS Football leaders in every stats category, as well as historic leaders.
www.ncaa.com
Here are all of Purdy's drives down one score with a few minutes to go. Add in the Clemson one.
Yea, I guess I am thinking a late 4th quarter drive. The Iowa drive started in the 3rd quarter. It did end up being the game winner, and was certainly clutch, but not a late drive.
I think Kansas, didn't Gilbert miss one or two late kicks? I know we didn't score but we certainly were in position.
God this season sucks so bad. If we were - below average on offense we'd be 6-6 or maybe 7-5.
If we were average on offense we could have won 8-9
God this season sucks so bad. If we were - below average on offense we'd be 6-6 or maybe 7-5.
If we were average on offense we could have won 8-9
The discrepancy between Sanders and Dekkers looks worse than it really is since Sanders missed 1+ games due to injury. He has officially played in 10 games but missed a large part of others. Even with the 10 games played it is Dekkers 39.4 attempts per game, Sanders 36.8 a/g. JT Daniels is averaging 32.7 a/g but was averaging 36.6 in the first 8 games of the season before Green started really cutting into his playing time.
True, Dekkers has had the benefit (if you can call it that) of being the only guy to take snaps at QB for Iowa State this year (Becht and Cook have 6 att combined).
Ranking the main elements of the offense from best to worst --
Xavier Hutchinson
Hunter Dekkers
TEs and other WRs (a collective "meh")
RBs who miss holes and can't stay healthy
the tire fire that is the offensive line
Xavier Hutchinson
Hunter Dekkers
TEs and other WRs (a collective "meh")
RBs who miss holes and can't stay healthy
the tire fire that is the offensive line
Dekkers may be the only the Big12 QB who hasn't missed time this year. Every team, save for Baylor (I think), has started at least two different QB's.
I would assume the service academies wouldn't, but not sure on any others.
No, in the link you posted there is only one per line. It probably is because either a team doesn't throw enough for their QB to have enough attempts to qualify - like Navy - or they have used multiple QBs and none of them have enough attempts due to splitting up the attempts.
With no help coming. Have to hope Brock comes back strong and can stay healthy, Norton continues to improve, and huge strides needed from Silas and Sanders. The latter two really make me nervous anytime I see them in the game. Just can't be trusted, but they're all we have.
Was surprised by how proficient Dekkers looks from a stats perspective so looked into yards per point scored for the top 100 total yard teams. Iowa State is at 18 yards per point scored when the average of the top 100 is 13.5 (~3.5 standard deviations from the mean). I'm sure average starting field position would explain a lot of it, but I think the offenses issue is converting production into points. For comparison, Iowa's offense is atrocious from a total yards perspective but is 14.5 yards per point (less than 1 STDev) so they are significantly better at converting their production into points.
Mostly you're right. TCU started the year with Chandler Morris, but he has only attempted 20 passes all season. Shapen has done most of the lifting at QB for Baylor, he may have missed time in one game, but Baylor also has the #6 rusher in the conference in freshman Richard Reese, makes life so much easier for a young QB.
We have won 1 Big12 game to this point. For me there is open competition at EVERY position. Sure guys like Tampa, Purchase, Freyler, Anderson and Noel can probably be penciled in as starters (if they return) in 2023- but there needs to be a culture of change this off season.
Dekkers has had an OK season. But I don't feel I have seen much (if any) improvement from game 1 to game 11. Sure that can be blamed on coaching/play calling.
But I haven't seen enough good plays by Dekkers, in the type of offense I would like ISU to run, to say he's my QB in 2023. IMO his stats are misleading because he throws the ball a lot and he throws a ton of meaningless short passes. Sure teams are going to let us complete a pass 5 yard pass on 3rd and 8.
Where does Dekkers need to improve?
Dekkers has had an OK season. But I don't feel I have seen much (if any) improvement from game 1 to game 11. Sure that can be blamed on coaching/play calling.
But I haven't seen enough good plays by Dekkers, in the type of offense I would like ISU to run, to say he's my QB in 2023. IMO his stats are misleading because he throws the ball a lot and he throws a ton of meaningless short passes. Sure teams are going to let us complete a pass 5 yard pass on 3rd and 8.
Where does Dekkers need to improve?
- His footwork & mechanics. He has fallen in love with side arm motion. That's great sometimes, but his passes also tend to float.
- His decision making at the mesh point. Just get the feeling he decides ahead of time to run the ball or hand off.
- His accuracy is bad. He struggles to hit guys on the run. I think we have gone to a lot of passes thrown to a spot, to help compensate. But this results in our YAC to be bad.
- For a guy with a big arm, I haven't seen many long completions.
- I also think he loves throws outside the hash marks. Needs to be more comfortable throwing 10-20 yard routes between the hash marks. Sure some of this is limitation of ISU's passing routes.
It's why I give him a little pass on some of the INTs more attempts mean more chances for an int and when it's that heavy of a discrepancy then teams are going to plan for it. I'm sure he feels tons of pressure to make something happen. He can definitely improve on reading the defense still but he's young.
This is probably true or close to true. According to Big 12 stats Dekkers, Duggan (TCU), Shapen (BU), and Smith (TTU) have all played 11 games but haven't some of those even missed part of games due to injury?
- Duggan only had 3 attempts at Colorado to start the season.
- Smith started off the season averaging 42.6 attempts per game in the first 5 games but has only attempted 8 passes since even though he has appeared in all of the games.
