***The Da Vinci Code Mafia***

[ImJustKCClone]

Yes I'm aware. Going along with the chart and making a joke. Although I kinda wish I wasn't known so early. Adds pressure of knowing people are going to follow my leads and I haven't been all that great at finding mafia so far.

Just checking. There were a lot of posts...could have been easy to overlook.

 

[Cy$]

I put the people I saw online but were not participating in the game off to the right as some of those people were on my list. A question I have is does the mafia get a list similar to what Arob got? Arob decided to inform us of the clues that he got via pm.

I was looking back and saw this post.

Vote Ctown.

. The timing is suspicious on this vote. This was before Arob revealed Ctown was inno after the anagram. The voting was me at 5, oldman at 2. Was this a move to hide in the background without pushing on me or a bad coincidence? Benefits are:

1) Mafia got the same clues as Arob, they found out Ctown was inno and decided to push ctown up for later before the rest of the town knew he was inno.
2) Use Ctown to hide since it was me (a reg inno) and oldman (confirmed mafia) at the top. Pushing me would look bad for people voting later and oldman is scum so he wouldn't want to push there either.

Would Fitzy do something this obvious? I can see him doing it thinking he can weasel out of it for later.
Another thing I was looking at was participation in the game thread related to salty's clue. Fitzy has been MIA throughout the whole day and this is cause he's helping the mafia team solve the puzzles that Arob has gotten.

Vote Fitzy.

 

[azhuth09]

First of all, why did I bring this over from MU for this game? I noticed the puzzle from salty's first post and it would be in the innocents best interest to be collaborative and help solve the game. I'll get to this later on who I'm voting for.

My initial scum list was people that I saw being active but were not contributing to help solve the game. I brought the game here to see if those people would participate or hide to avoid suspicion.

To the game...I wasn't looking at or cared much about who said who was mafia. It could be useful but it's easy to join in and manipulate the results if you're mafia. I was looking at how people responded under a time crunch and me putting pressure on people to play.

spiker - I liked his answers. No b.s. one way or another. prob inno.
KC - wish she'd take it more seriously but think she's inno.
moores - seemed indecisive at times but wasn't terrible.
azhuth - skipped quite a few people but his answers were similar to spiker. inno for now
andy - no b.s. answers. inno for now
Clonies - I'd rather he play live but he played. I have other reasons to be suspicious of him though.
JM - most likely mafia out of the list that played. One of the things I look for is a huge number of mafia or a huge number of townies picked. JM had 12 mafia players picked, easy to manipulate to hide who his teammates are if the list is used later. I have other people on my radar though.
Psy - He knows this game so he knows what I was looking for in answers. He had quite a few mafia picks as well at 10. He had all 4 players that are kinda known as correct...my eyes on you psy.

Part 2 next.

For the record, I skipped one group of five because I got pulled off for work and thought we were done. My column just looks like a lot of white because they are in 2 groups plus I predicted one of the not so innocent not so mafia group (called it vig for short) and called cash the albino hit man (silas/scum)

 

[Dandy]

Hey, @VikesFan22:

Wouldn't eat that if my life depended on it.

 

[Fitzy]

I put the people I saw online but were not participating in the game off to the right as some of those people were on my list. A question I have is does the mafia get a list similar to what Arob got? Arob decided to inform us of the clues that he got via pm.

I was looking back and saw this post.

. The timing is suspicious on this vote. This was before Arob revealed Ctown was inno after the anagram. The voting was me at 5, oldman at 2. Was this a move to hide in the background without pushing on me or a bad coincidence? Benefits are:

1) Mafia got the same clues as Arob, they found out Ctown was inno and decided to push ctown up for later before the rest of the town knew he was inno.
2) Use Ctown to hide since it was me (a reg inno) and oldman (confirmed mafia) at the top. Pushing me would look bad for people voting later and oldman is scum so he wouldn't want to push there either.

Would Fitzy do something this obvious? I can see him doing it thinking he can weasel out of it for later.
Another thing I was looking at was participation in the game thread related to salty's clue. Fitzy has been MIA throughout the whole day and this is cause he's helping the mafia team solve the puzzles that Arob has gotten.

Vote Fitzy.

MU has somehow made you worse at mafia.

 

[VikesFan22]

Wouldn't eat that if my life depended on it.

Vote Dandy

 

[Cy$]

MU has somehow made you worse at mafia.

Lock him up boys, he’s scum

 

[bsaltyman]

Vote Dandy

Vikes, this needs to be bolded to count. Otherwise, our vote count is:

1 Vikes - Fitzy (8:35)
1 Cy$ - Discy (11:03)
1 JM4CY - moores (11:04)
1 Fitzy - Cy$ (11:52)

 

[VikesFan22]

Vikes, this needs to be bolded to count. Otherwise, our vote count is:

1 Vikes - Fitzy (8:35)
1 Cy$ - Discy (11:03)
1 JM4CY - moores (11:04)
1 Fitzy - Cy$ (11:52)

I know but thanks for checking. It was a warning shot at dandy.

 

[ISUCyclones2015]

I put the people I saw online but were not participating in the game off to the right as some of those people were on my list. A question I have is does the mafia get a list similar to what Arob got? Arob decided to inform us of the clues that he got via pm.

I was looking back and saw this post.

. The timing is suspicious on this vote. This was before Arob revealed Ctown was inno after the anagram. The voting was me at 5, oldman at 2. Was this a move to hide in the background without pushing on me or a bad coincidence? Benefits are:

1) Mafia got the same clues as Arob, they found out Ctown was inno and decided to push ctown up for later before the rest of the town knew he was inno.
2) Use Ctown to hide since it was me (a reg inno) and oldman (confirmed mafia) at the top. Pushing me would look bad for people voting later and oldman is scum so he wouldn't want to push there either.

Would Fitzy do something this obvious? I can see him doing it thinking he can weasel out of it for later.
Another thing I was looking at was participation in the game thread related to salty's clue. Fitzy has been MIA throughout the whole day and this is cause he's helping the mafia team solve the puzzles that Arob has gotten.

Vote Fitzy.

I got the same clues that Arob got and he's posted them all.

"
1 1 2 3 5 8 1 0 3 1
Poisons worry fiction
Dead ominous slip

It seams that there was also a third line of text that had already been wiped away..."

That's the entire thing. Seams I thought was a clue but Salty confirmed in this thread that it was just bad English.

 

[CtownCyclone]

PSY has my spidey sense twitching. I agree with those who have said that he doesn't seem to be the type of player to spill those kinds of beans, what with how well he sat on information in the last game.

And he immediately jumped in to put the kibosh on voting for Vikes after I speculated on his vote yesterday.

Vote PSY.

 

[azhuth09]

Going to throw out a vote vikes and see what happens

 

[PSYclone22]

First of all, why did I bring this over from MU for this game? I noticed the puzzle from salty's first post and it would be in the innocents best interest to be collaborative and help solve the game. I'll get to this later on who I'm voting for.

My initial scum list was people that I saw being active but were not contributing to help solve the game. I brought the game here to see if those people would participate or hide to avoid suspicion.

To the game...I wasn't looking at or cared much about who said who was mafia. It could be useful but it's easy to join in and manipulate the results if you're mafia. I was looking at how people responded under a time crunch and me putting pressure on people to play.

spiker - I liked his answers. No b.s. one way or another. prob inno.
KC - wish she'd take it more seriously but think she's inno.
moores - seemed indecisive at times but wasn't terrible.
azhuth - skipped quite a few people but his answers were similar to spiker. inno for now
andy - no b.s. answers. inno for now
Clonies - I'd rather he play live but he played. I have other reasons to be suspicious of him though.
JM - most likely mafia out of the list that played. One of the things I look for is a huge number of mafia or a huge number of townies picked. JM had 12 mafia players picked, easy to manipulate to hide who his teammates are if the list is used later. I have other people on my radar though.
Psy - He knows this game so he knows what I was looking for in answers. He had quite a few mafia picks as well at 10. He had all 4 players that are kinda known as correct...my eyes on you psy.

Part 2 next.

"Clonies - I'd rather he play live but he played. I have other reasons to be suspicious of him though."

I think him publicly solving the write-up is a pretty heavy sign he's inno for me. I'm curious what else you are considering for him.

Separately, vote moores for some shaky answers, worst of which was his Ctown being "probably innocent, not really sure".

If he's probably innocent, what's to be unsure about?

 

[VikesFan22]

Going to throw out a vote vikes and see what happens

What's your reasoning?

 

[azhuth09]

What's your reasoning?

***** and gigs

 

[Cy$]

"Clonies - I'd rather he play live but he played. I have other reasons to be suspicious of him though."

I think him publicly solving the write-up is a pretty heavy sign he's inno for me. I'm curious what else you are considering for him.

Separately, vote moores for some shaky answers, worst of which was his Ctown being "probably innocent, not really sure".

If he's probably innocent, what's to be unsure about?

i didn't like him trying to push for a different vote for oldman. I doubt he'd do that if he was scum but it looks sketchy.

 

[Cy$]

MU has somehow made you worse at mafia.

hard to go up after Tiger King and the MU town sweep. All downhill from here.

 

[CoKane]

Some good theories out there right now. I'm gonna vote Psy for now

 

[VikesFan22]

I'm trying to determine when mafia would have started voting for oldman. I imagine at least one would have voted for him prior to the puzzle reveal.

22 oldman - Vikes (11:53), Andybernard (12:10), 2015 (1:23), Azhuth (4:17), CyArob (5:38), Cy$ (5:44), CTown (6:30), Cyfan13 (6:40), moores (6:41), cleaver (6:42), Michael (6:48), North (6:54), discy (6:57), clonies (6:57), PSY (7:13), KC (7:17), Fitzy (7:31), WDSM (7:32), SaraV (7:39), CYme (7:41), CoKane (7:59), JM4CY (8:12)

 

[VikesFan22]

I wanted to confirm that Arob revealed it. That only leaves andy, 2015, azhuth and me. Maybe my theory is wrong.

The other thing to think about is how quickly mafia would have piled on following the reveal.