Cyclone Fanatic Expectations

[Dormeezy]

Quoted from 4-star recruit thread:

For those who choose not to pay for CR or CN, it's your choice. But your choice also means that you cannot expect to receive the info from CR or CN here. And any attempt to do so just puts Jeremy in a bad situation.

Nobody here expects or tries to recieve premium information from CR and CN, but what we do expect is to be able to freely read what is posted here, discuss it with dignity, and not have to deal with the little hissy fits that seem to occur on a regular basis. It's getting to the point where these arguments are taking place so frequently, it's taking the fun out of reading the threads.

The purpose of this discussion board is for the spread of information and opinions of fellow Cyclone fans. As mentioned, more people than just Paul and Jeremy have sources. If someone learns something through a legitimate source, they should be allowed to share it with the rest of us without fearing the wrath of McCarthyism knocking at their door.

Now, let's talk about this 4-star rumored recruit. Does anybody know his name yet?

 

[Jer]

Bass is the recruit that recommitted.

Also, I agree with you that people need to relax when it comes to info on recruits. While other people may make a living on the subject, they aren't the only ones privileged to the information.

You made a good point, a lot of people have a lot of sources and it's not hard to find somebody that would know things before they get posted. There are a lot of people in the know and it only takes one to get the info out there. There is a lot of news and only a portion of it is either worthy of writing about or is printable based on what a source may have asked of us. I know a lot of things that would not be good news to post about but there are other people that may have the same info and glad to share it.

It all depends on who you know and what they know. Follow the below example...

A recruit calls ISU to make a verbal, the coach relays it to the staff and the staff puts it down on paper. The papers may need to be passed on for future uses or for the NCAA. The player may then give word to a reporter, family, friends or others.

As you can see, there are a lot of potential sources involved, not just a random recruiting reporter. It's a complicated web of information and sources and it's sometimes harder to figure out what dot to call than it is to get the actual info.

 

[06_CY]

If people choose to pay for that stuff, good for them; I choose not to. If you read info on a premium site and wish to spread it, just say some thing like "My buddy told me..." or "My buddy talked to someone who has inside info..." :biggrin9gp:

My friend tells me whats up whenever there is something worthwhile on those boards; not enough worthwhile info for me to cough up the cash. Somehow I seem to find out about "Premium" info before my buddy tells me anyway.

 

[JokersWild]

I'm lucky in the fact that I'm 2nd cousins with Coach Chizik. So, if you people want PREMIUM info, just send me some cash.

 

[billdo00]

i think the problem most people have with it are the time-tables that the info shows up somewhere else, then here. i dont tend to see info like that "confirmed" here and then end up somewhere else. its a ligitimate concern but the premium sites can't do much about it and the moderators cant always control what is from sources or from other sites.

 

[JokersWild]

i think the problem most people have with it are the time-tables that the info shows up somewhere else, then here. i dont tend to see info like that "confirmed" here and then end up somewhere else. its a ligitimate concern but the premium sites can't do much about it and the moderators cant always control what is from sources or from other sites.

Agree. It's basically a message/gossip board. So, there are always people that want to be THE person who lets people in on stuff. It's the same way in any social setting whether it be work, or just a gathering of friends.

 

[Angie]

i think the problem most people have with it are the time-tables that the info shows up somewhere else, then here. i dont tend to see info like that "confirmed" here and then end up somewhere else. its a ligitimate concern but the premium sites can't do much about it and the moderators cant always control what is from sources or from other sites.

You've got a really good point here, billdo - there is no way for us to know what info is from where. For every source that someone on a so-called "rival" site has, someone here probably has either a similar or the exact SAME source, whether they post it or not. I would argue that there is info from Jeremy that has been posted here first (notably, Mac's resignation/firing, while NOBODY got the Chizik hiring right). I think a major reason for that is that Jeremy probably has some of the same or similar sources to others - there are how many employees of the athletic department, and then how many more members of the teams? Someone's roommate's sister told someone's brother something... and so on, and so on. This comes back to your post - there really isn't any way for us to be sure of anything.

You are correct, however - Jeremy posted it both here and in the other thread, that it is not cool to gank info from premium sites and put the info here without any other sources. This is a courtesy to those sites. This site also does not allow threads/posts bashing any other site, whether or not that is reciprocated.

To be clear, however... To those who talk about Jeremy in a negative manner, saying that he has stolen information from other sites:

1. Jeremy does not have a premium membership on the main site in question. In fact, the admins from the sites ban each other's IP addresses, so this is impossible for Jeremy to directly steal information.

2. If any information shows up here posted by Jeremy and is later than it being posted on another site, it's important to remember that this board is not Jeremy's job. This is not a source of any valid income for him, as it is for the owner of other sites. If you put Jeremy on your buddy list, you will see how infrequently he is actually able to sign on during the day, due to a +50 hr/week job. It's improbable that he would be able to get every piece of info up here as quickly as someone whose job it is to do so.

I don't mean to sound like I'm speaking for Jeremy or the site at large - these are just my thoughts, not those of anyone else. I hope those who come to this site enjoy it as much as I do (even if they've gone to sleep reading this post :rolleyes5cz: ). Hopefully the in-fighting will cease, since we're all just here to support ISU sports!!!

GO CYCLONES!!!

 

[JokersWild]

Is "gank" a real word? I might have to look that one up, but if it is, I'm going to start using it.

 

[JokersWild]

Well, I'll be. Gank is real word. It's also a noun for fake crack cocaine. So, in theory, I could gank some gank. Nice.

 

[C.John]

Well said Angie. Saves me from typing my own response, so thanks.

 

[Angie]

Well, I'll be. Gank is real word. It's also a noun for fake crack cocaine. So, in theory, I could gank some gank. Nice.

LMAO - you of all people should know better than to doubt me on my urban slang! :rofl8yi: Good pull on "gank[ing] some gank" - I might have to start using that.

Well said Angie. Saves me from typing my own response, so thanks.

Feel free to expound on some of the points - I was not even sure I made sense to anyone other than myself...

 

[Ed]

Not saying Jeremy does or does not access paid sites for information, just want to point out that when you say:

"1. Jeremy does not have a premium membership on the main site in question. In fact, the admins from the sites ban each other's IP addresses, so this is impossible for Jeremy to directly steal information."

you are incorrect in saying it is impossible. It is too easy to get around IP address bans. Simply changing ISP is an easy legit way. Half assed hackers can give you plenty of less legit ways.

 

[Angie]

I do agree with you that it is possible to mask IP address, etc., Ed. You're correct. FWIW, I can see the IP's that Jeremy has used throughout his entire time on this site, and they're always from the same host - I know you weren't accusing him of anything, just pointing that out.

Jer doesn't have the time to be on THIS site that much during the day, however, let alone another site.

 

[Jer]

Well you are correct, it could be done but it would hardly be worth the effort. And anything can be done; elections can be stolen, ISU winning the BCS Title 'could' happen, etc

I think everybody is pretty much on the same page, it just doesn't always come across that way through posts on a message board. I know that most people on here understand the courtesy involved and respect the unwritten code of ethics that most follow.

Not saying Jeremy does or does not access paid sites for information, just want to point out that when you say:

"1. Jeremy does not have a premium membership on the main site in question. In fact, the admins from the sites ban each other's IP addresses, so this is impossible for Jeremy to directly steal information."

you are incorrect in saying it is impossible. It is too easy to get around IP address bans. Simply changing ISP is an easy legit way. Half assed hackers can give you plenty of less legit ways.

 

[JokersWild]

no diggity a boohiney from the cube would be down with the urban slang.

 

[C.John]

no diggity a boohiney from the cube would be down with the urban slang.

...Huh??

 

[ISUFan22]

I should have been specific that I had a source other than CR when discussing the recruit info. I feel had I gone that route though, I would have been accused of lying and tabbed a "CR info thief". Damned if you do, damned if you don't. That thread was doomed from the start - no matter if I participated or not. That's speculation by myself of course.

I first caught wind of it via CR - that I won't deny. Yet I was quickly informed of the commit from a different source, unrelated to CR.

Regardless, I apologize for any part I had in escalating the situation.

 

[Jer]

Sounds good, I think most understand. Like everything on any website, it's just subject to everybody's interpretation and understanding of the events. I think we all want to keep from posting info from other sites and when the timing on when somebody posts something elsewhere and it gets posted here is so short, it really creates a lot of room for tension to grow.

As long as we all agree we like to keep things on the high road, we'll have a great time sharing info and opinions while having a ton of fun along the way.

 

[ceeboe]

Whats hard is knowing what info is ok to share, and what is not. The recruits and coaching hires are tough ones to talk about until they are completely public. Obviously this would all be new unreleased info that most members and people of the public do no know about.

Now, the headline on the Tampa 2 that was wrote up, I feel was a great story to share. Its already public, but just a story written for premium members. As long as their is no stealing of journalism involved, that subject and others like it could really entertain members on every site.

 

[cycloneworld]

I have a serious question for the CR, CN subscribers: Why do you have your subscription? I'm not being facetious here either. You pay $100 per year to get information you can get hours or a day later. Is it the magazine?

I've never subscribed to either nor have I really been interested in doing so, so I'm just curious that's all.