***Official 2026 World Cup Thread***

If you come in for a slide tackle with your studs up and connect with their leg, it's relatively standard to receive a red card. You can tell how few Americans watch soccer and are essentially using their knowledge of targeting to guide their perception of fouls. It's not really about intent. It's danger and recklessness. There is some bad luck involved.
I get that spiking someone is dangerous, even if it's unintentional. My point is running someone over is also dangerous, usually intentional, and is typically just a common foul.

One unintentional, but dangerous play is given a red card and multi-game suspension.
One intentional and dangerous play is given a normal foul with not even a yellow card.
 
I get that spiking someone is dangerous, even if it's unintentional. My point is running someone over is also dangerous, usually intentional, and is typically just a common foul.

One unintentional, but dangerous play is given a red card and multi-game suspension.
One intentional and dangerous play is given a normal foul with not even a yellow card.
That's football! The rules are the rules, except when we don't enforce them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Letterkenny
Yes but a late tackle is much more dangerous than a shove.
Agree. The one England got called for last night wasn't even late though, he beat the Mexican player to the ball. Balogun's wasn't late either, and wasn't really a tackle. Both guys ran into each other, he lost his balance and just happened to step on the back of the Bosnian player's leg.
 
There's a lot more to it. Every player that goes in for a hard tackle is aware of their tackling technique and what the consequences are if they arrive late, from the wrong angle, or with studs up. All challenges are not equal.

Regarding the first part of your post, good refs will establish how much contact they allow and stay mostly consistent with it. The issue becomes when contact is allowed once and then never again.

In general, the same contact is not treated the same if it's not affecting the flow of the game. That's why you'll see a lot of tugging on jerseys get ignored or a defender shielding a ball over the endline that gets laid out with no whistle.
I guess I've never watched a match with any level of consistency. I don't even have a problem with inconsistent calls. It's the nature of sports. My beef is with the extreme harshness of a red card when everyone acknowledges that refereeing is really difficult, and calls are inconsistent. Same reason I don't like targeting in college resulting in suspensions. A potentially missed call (including calls that should be made, but aren't) shouldn't have that dramatic of an influence on the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frak
I get that spiking someone is dangerous, even if it's unintentional. My point is running someone over is also dangerous, usually intentional, and is typically just a common foul.

One unintentional, but dangerous play is given a red card and multi-game suspension.
One intentional and dangerous play is given a normal foul with not even a yellow card.
There are very few cases of players running someone over. A lot of guys fall down, but we're not seeing American football style tackles going on. A lot of guys on the ground, but that's more performance than anything to highlight a disadvantage in play. Keep watching, and you'll start to tell the difference between a common foul, yellow, and red. You are free to use your shoulders and body for positioning. Upper body battles aren't nearly as dangerous as potential ankle and knee injuries.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coolerifyoudid
Agree. The one England got called for last night wasn't even late though, he beat the Mexican player to the ball. Balogun's wasn't late either, and wasn't really a tackle. Both guys ran into each other, he lost his balance and just happened to step on the back of the Bosnian player's leg.
Yeah but he missed the ball because he was out of control. It was bad skill, bad technique, and some bad luck. Easy red.
 
I'm not trying hard at all. The sport is littered with inconsistency.
Every sport is. Just don't watch. I guarantee nobody is gonna break into your house and force you to watch a game against your will.

There's a weird segment of the population that thinks everyone wants to hear about why they don't like soccer. I really don't get what they hope to achieve by regurgitating the same things over and over.