For somebody that doesn't drive a lot you might want to look at a Nissan Leaf. Occasionally you can get a screaming deal on those. They have pretty poor range but it doesn't sound like you need that.
I am in watching and learning mode. Don't really need an auto right now, Das Audi is 11 this year but only has 45K on it and it has new all-season booties so good to go for a bit.