I'm not here to defend him at all and I agree completely with you. The only reason I watch his reviews is because we seem to have similar tastes in Pizza. I'm not into the "char" as much as he is, but I do prefer a crispy, well done pizza, where the cheese has a good amount of brown malliard reaction to it.Sounds like a ****** critic tbh.
A good critic will generally judge something based on how well it is achieving the style it is aiming for. Like, you wouldn't judge a dumb comedy movie the same way you'd judge an oscar contender.
That being said, his reviews are **** really, it's all about flop, how charred the bottom of the pizza looks and if it's crispy or not. There is never any talk about the flavor of the sauce or the flavor of the crust, just whether or not it's crispy. They aren't really "reviews" as much as, "This isn't my style" or "This is my style." He does get views though and places he gives high scores to, do blow up.