***Tiger King Mafia Thread!***

So I got the Tiger on day 1. I gave it to PSY night one which meant that it was gone immediately. I gave some light hints that I passed it to him to see how he responded. I was killed night two...

Ah! Thanks for posting that. I wanted to ask once the game ended. I wanted to push it as a topic at one point but figured it'd only lead to bad outcomes for us. That's why we never responded to the "where's the tiger" posts.
 
If i was $, I might have just not used the kill on the last night and made the noob decide between him and cmjh. Salty was more sure $ was inno so I don’t think it would’ve been too hard. And left no doubt.
It had occurred to me last night that this game could not have possibly been more torture for me if someone had designed it that way, with everyone in on the joke except for me. I had a special role to start, but both of the innos I could pm died immediately, and I was in the dark. As it turns out, the mafia members kind of did design it to bring me along for the ride and torment me. Your scenario would have been perfect, and I have no idea how I would have voted, but I probably would have thought way to hard about it.
 
We had a hell of a time figuring out who the doc was. We were convinced it was Vikes or Cubs for a little
Lol good. That makes me feel better. I was dropping hits as subtly as I could the whole game. Voting for doc once. Use the word diagnose, healthy, **** like that. I felt like I practically had to out myself or I would of gotten lynched that last day.
 
This. Mafia would always vote for mafia so if even one innocent voted for mafia, mafia would win. You can't rely on people voting for who actually deserves to win.
Hmm. Maybe just leave it up to the mayor... Both remaining players could plead their case for why they and their team deserve the win, and the mayor picks the winner based on whoever gives the best argument.
 
Hmm. Maybe just leave it up to the mayor... Both remaining players could plead their case for why they and their team deserve the win, and the mayor picks the winner based on whoever gives the best argument.
Like a Julie Probst or Jeff Chen. Forget the jury.
 
Hmm. Maybe just leave it up to the mayor... Both remaining players could plead their case for why they and their team deserve the win, and the mayor picks the winner based on whoever gives the best argument.
Honestly, the innos had a ton of stuff go against them early on. Joe Exotic being first out. The tiger getting past to mafia first night. Detective outing himself early. But there were also quite a few ghost posts that helped them a ton.
 
When was it known I was the Doc?

I went back and forth with Moores and could not decide if I should save vikes or me the night vikes got the axe. I ended up choosing to save myself and screwed up. Then the following day I could of saved myself and bought us both more time maybe and made a difference. Ended up choosing wrong we both died quickly.

I really wish I had played more before getting that roll. I had no clue and nothing to go off of past games and tendencies and stuff and was basically picking at random every night. Chose mafia multiple times. Psy’s stupid charts were seducing me. It was fun though. Good game y’all. Even you cash.
When I asked Moores if you were and he said yes :)

I had similar situations in the Mandalorian Mafia a few games ago and I played many games before that. I also got it wrong and cost us. Doc is a hard role. No shame.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JM4CY
Hmm. Maybe just leave it up to the mayor... Both remaining players could plead their case for why they and their team deserve the win, and the mayor picks the winner based on whoever gives the best argument.

If you did everyone as a whole, and didn't reveal roles, it'd be interesting to see if how many people the mafia member fooled. Plus the mafia member gets to pick who they are up against with that last kill.
 
I could put on evenly matched settings and stream a 2K game. Last mafia chooses their basketball team, last inno chooses theirs. May the 2K gods choose.
 
Ties should be decided by .8ball

2015_2_23_magic8ball-thumb-1020x1039-880844.png