***Tiger King Mafia Thread!***
- Thread starter moores2
- Start date
I spent like 2 hours last night skimming through this entire thread, and it was a few things along the way that changed my mind. I feel like CYme and Psy threw cmjh under the bus a couple of times in a way that makes me think cmjh is innocent. The day 5 vote also makes more sense if you think cmjh is innocent. Cy$ was the first to call out CoKane day 2. Maybe that was just a clever ploy to out Carol Baskin, but he’s consistently seemed innocent throughout the game to me. I did feel like you were pretty innocent as well, but you were also quieter at times during the game. There wasn’t a big flaw that you did to out yourself or something though.
okay that's fair. I do not know one way or the other if cmjh or Cy$ is mafia, but I know I'm reg inno. After reading through everything yesterday and last night, I'll lay out my thoughts.
The final mafia player is desperate, if I was the final 1 of 2 mafia left, I would've probably played it very similar to cmjh. Realize that the mindset is moving toward your last partner first 1/2 of yesterday, so you vote "with authority" for them to start the day to make it seem like they lead the vote. Secondly, yesterday, immediately after Farnsy was announced he "celebrated" and deflected the looking to Cy$ in the same post. Then consistently play the "I'm not sure, what do you think" until one or more innos change their minds.
It seems like you've done your diggin on the voting records and this thread, so not sure what more I can do to change your mind. But I know you will be upset when I come back inno if this truly is the final day.
/rant
Honestly if Cy$ played the long con of leading the vote on Carole Baskins I would be thoroughly impressed. That is some next level planning without any forsure you make it this far.
I know you did. So that is why I'm trying to help you see that and talk through it.
You’re the only person I 100% trust here...I do think cmjh is more mafia than srj though...
I can't speak to cmjh's legitimacy when he says he'll never play again, cause I don't know him as well as others on here probably do. But I think saying something that definite does cause pause in people.
Honestly, can't say. There have been some clever mafia plays so far. And hell Cy$ still could have the most clever of all.
However, I don't think a lone mafia member would be telling you he thinks it might be someone other than the person you voted for(like Cy$ did in post #1590), If I was lone mafia and a mind had been set on anyone other than me, I'd be jumping all over that. Not making you rethink yourself. That is why I am leaning cmjh, along with my theory I laid out earlier this morning.
