I have a set of Henckels Four Star and a set of Shun Premiers. I still use my 8" henckel 90% of the time. It's easier steel to sharpen and it's what i learned knife skills with. The thin Japanese knives are really nice for detail work but they're easy to chip if you don't have good knife skills or understand what thin/hard steel does. Accidentally put torque on the blade cutting carrots and it will chip. Get a little aggressive deboning a chicken, chip. Blade maintenance is infinitely more important than the blade itself.