Except we have been generally terrible at the scheme part when there isn't someone dedicated to coach ST. Cost many a game in this era.
I just don’t think that a specific ST coordinator matters. First off, if that person is replacing an actual position coach, he's going to have to be able to recruit. Second, that person has to not only be able to coach kickers and punters, he has to know protection and coverage plus fakes, etc. How many people are out there with that skill set? I'd rather have an analyst that can coach kickers and then the various assistants be in charge of a unit or a specific area. I mean, do you really want a kicking coach telling our OL how to block on punt team or FG team vs Clanton?
I don't disagree that ST has been generally bad under Campbell. My opinion is that a lot of that is not being able to get kickoffs into the endzone, not being able to get punts off quick enough, and flat out missing FGs. The 2020 team got burned on kickoffs repeatedly because we were scoring a bunch and never got touchbacks. I just think that fixing K and P goes a LONG ways into having good STs. And right behind that is having good returners and gunners. We've made some pretty good steps forward in most of those areas.