I was referring to the "your idea won't make anything better" comment. I disagree. I think it will.
You're not a mod, so don't worry about the impact on their time. Let them make the decision. If they don't want to do this idea, it won't happen.
Why are you fighting this so hard? If it's as bad an idea as you think it is, then it will die a natural death. But if it survives, then maybe it wasn't such a bad idea. I don't see how it hurts you other than having one extra thread showing up in the list that you can simply ignore.