***Official 2023 Chicago Cubs Thread***

Ok, here's my GM moves between now and the start of 24.

Trade Barnhart after the season to make room for Amaya.

Pay the buyout on Bellinger for PCA to take over CF.

Trade Davis to the Royals for Chapman. Extend him 1 or 2 at 5mil per. (Making 3.5 this year but in his mid 30s) still threw 103 the other day.

Pay the buyout on Hendricks.

Teade Bote at the deadline. (He's 5.5 mil)

Extend Stroman.

Take option on Smyly at 10mil.

Sign Ohtani ( guessing 55mil per)
No need. His is a mutual option, and if he keeps this up, there's zero chance he takes one extra year at $25M over what he'll get in FA.
 
No need. His is a mutual option, and if he keeps this up, there's zero chance he takes one extra year at $25M over what he'll get in FA.
His base is 12 this year and if they don't agree on the mutual for next year they owe him 5.5 mil.
 
His base is 12 this year and if they don't agree on the mutual for next year they owe him 5.5 mil.
It's a mutual option, Bellinger will get a bigger long term deal if he keeps playing like he has so far so just enjoy him while we have him. If it weren't for all the OF prospects in the system and needing payroll to make a run at Ohtani I'd be all in for extending him now.

BTW gotta love Amaya enjoying the moment and singing some Go Cubs Go


He'll probably heading to Iowa when Gomes comes off the IL which is actually a promotion for him but hope he can stay healthy and keep developing as Cubs need a young catcher in the system with Gomes age.
 
It's a mutual option, Bellinger will get a bigger long term deal if he keeps playing like he has so far so just enjoy him while we have him. If it weren't for all the OF prospects in the system and needing payroll to make a run at Ohtani I'd be all in for extending him now.

BTW gotta love Amaya enjoying the moment and singing some Go Cubs Go


He'll probably heading to Iowa when Gomes comes off the IL which is actually a promotion for him but hope he can stay healthy and keep developing as Cubs need a young catcher in the system with Gomes age.
Bellinger will absolutely get a bigger deal. When he rejects the mutual he'll get a 5.5 mil .

Amaya will not have options next year. Gomes will be the one they keep. Barnhart will be odd man out unless they choose to let Amaya go. Which they won't.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CYdTracked
Nice comeback win today. Still leaving way to many RISP. Should have had 8+ runs. Still not sold on Suzuki.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CYdTracked
Nice comeback win today. Still leaving way to many RISP. Should have had 8+ runs. Still not sold on Suzuki.

Suzuki is the new Heyward problem—-got too much invested in him to do anything other than trot him out there everyday. Slugging .358 from the cleanup spot is by far the lowest in baseball if he were to stay in that spot in the lineup.
 
Bellinger will absolutely get a bigger deal. When he rejects the mutual he'll get a 5.5 mil .

Amaya will not have options next year. Gomes will be the one they keep. Barnhart will be odd man out unless they choose to let Amaya go. Which they won't.
No, he won't. The buyout is only paid if the club opts out of the remaining year(s). There is no buyout when the player elects FA, which is what Bellinger will (in all likelihood) do.
 
Suzuki is the new Heyward problem—-got too much invested in him to do anything other than trot him out there everyday. Slugging .358 from the cleanup spot is by far the lowest in baseball if he were to stay in that spot in the lineup.
Seems really premature. Avg 270s obp 350s. He was injured as well. If the slug is under 400 in a month you may have a point.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CYdTracked
No, he won't. The buyout is only paid if the club opts out of the remaining year(s). There is no buyout when the player elects FA, which is what Bellinger will (in all likelihood) do.
Wrong, 17.5 is guaranteed. 2023 base is 12. If you're going to tell me I'm wrong at minimum wait till I am because it happens a lot.

 
Makes you wonder if he destroyed the Cardinals staff how much better we would of having Gomes during Wiilson's time here?
Cardinals management and ownership deserves plenty of blame for Cardinals pitching problems too. Matz has been terrible since they signed him. Flaherty hasn't started 20 games since 2019 then Wainwright is now 40 years old and St Louis somehow ignored all of this in the offseason.
 
Wrong, 17.5 is guaranteed. 2023 base is 12. If you're going to tell me I'm wrong at minimum wait till I am because it happens a lot.

If that's the case, it's such a stupid way to structure the option. One would logically expect the team to pay the buyout if it wants to avoid paying even more for an extra season, but it makes no sense for them to pay it if they want to keep the player and the player declines. That's not so much a buyout as it is a way for the player to get free money.
 
If that's the case, it's such a stupid way to structure the option. One would logically expect the team to pay the buyout if it wants to avoid paying even more for an extra season, but it makes no sense for them to pay it if they want to keep the player and the player declines. That's not so much a buyout as it is a way for the player to get free money.
One would expect you to have at minimum review the contract before chiming in that I'm wrong.
 
One would expect you to have at minimum review the contract before chiming in that I'm wrong.
Why would I have done that, when the issue was apparently a fundamental misunderstanding of how a MO works? I made an assumption that was logically sound, and I was apparently wrong. Do you want a hug and a kiss to make up, or would you rather cry a little longer about someone saying that you were wrong on the internet?
 
Right not Madrigal or Velazquez would have to go down if he comes up. Morel can play all over the field much like Zobrist did so he could spell any of the regulars when they need a day off really.

They should probably figure out a way to get him in Chicago and get him on the field as much as possible IMO. Agree with the Zobrist comparison.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CYdTracked
Heading to the 14th inning. Just the 3rd time since the new extra inning format started.
 
Admittedly I haven’t watched a lot of baseball in the last 2 years, I forgot that MLB implemented the JV softball extra inning rules until today. It really destroyed the game for me. Call me old school but I lost all interest when I saw runners on second to start the inning.
 
I say we just go shootout style. Pick you batter 3 outs. How many dingers can they hit.
 
If that's the case, it's such a stupid way to structure the option. One would logically expect the team to pay the buyout if it wants to avoid paying even more for an extra season, but it makes no sense for them to pay it if they want to keep the player and the player declines. That's not so much a buyout as it is a way for the player to get free money.
Its stupid but most, if not all, mutual options are designed this way. There are many different financial reasons to do so. It is a way to guarantee extra money in the final year (positive for player) without that money impacting the current year (positive for team)

In Bellingers case, it was reported as a 1 year, $17.5 million deal. In actuality, he signed a 2 year, $24 million deal with a $5.5 million buyout after the first year. If he declines the option. He just needs a $6.5 million deal to match what he would’ve done, and he certainly will surpass that.

Rarely do I ever look at these deals and think they benefit the team but we saw a weird instance on this current team.

Drew Smyly declined a $10 million mutual option last year and we had to pay him $1 million. He then signed a $19 million over 2 year deal. He is making $8 million this year on the new contract, + $1 million from when he declined, which is less money then he would’ve received if he agreed to the option annually, but more money in terms of length of contract. Interestingly enough, the new contrast is also a mutual option in which the 3rd year is worth $10 million or $2.5 million buyout.
 
Admittedly I haven’t watched a lot of baseball in the last 2 years, I forgot that MLB implemented the JV softball extra inning rules until today. It really destroyed the game for me. Call me old school but I lost all interest when I saw runners on second to start the inning.

To me it's about pitching. Granted this one wound up still going 14, but these long, extra inning games can destroy a bullpen. I can understand wanting to try to get a game wrapped up.
 
I don't think any of us truly realized how awful Willson was/is at handling a staff and that's before you get into framing/blocking. I'm glad we didn't pay him and make him the guy that was going to be handling all these young kids over the next few years.

I'm pretty sure there were several of us on here who mentioned this very thing in the Cubs 2022 thread

My post from just after he went to the Cardinals:

kinda depends on how well you think he ages. I think the Cubs were smart to move on.

Considering that was the best contract he could get on the open market, seems many other teams agree.

One thing I'll be looking at is the STL staff ERA next year as compared to the last few years and the Cubs staff ERA compared to the last few years.

My belief is Contreras was so bad at game management that he made a noticeable difference in how many runs the Cubs gave up.



Also, you liked the post so I assume you agreed at the time lol
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron