Latest Bracketology

Two potential NCAA tournament 6 seeds (Ohio State and USC) lost Monday night. If ISU beats OSU and either Baylor or TT in the Big 12 tournament, I think they secure a 6 seed at the Dance.
Michigan State is a 6/7 seed too and they got curbstomped Tuesday night at Michigan. LSU also a 6 seed on many brackets plays at Arkansas tonight. Go Hogs.
 
Torvik projection right now...

First #7 seed behind Iowa and ahead of Murray State

Assume W against OSU and L against Baylor --

First #7 seed behind Iowa and ahead of Murray State (this is what the model expects to happen)

Assume W against OSU and Baylor --

Final #6 behind St. Mary's and ahead of Iowa

Assume L against OSU and Baylor --

Last #8 behind Boise State and ahead of San Diego State (91.4% chance to make tournament)

(seems like they need one more win to absolutely 100% lock in a berth)

I could add games in KC if anybody wants to see some specific scenario, but there are probably too many of them to keep doing this. But they're on track for a #7 hopefully with a win tonight.
 
Not sure we can crawl up much higher than a 6.

I was playing around with Torvik and going 2-2 in our next 4 games, meaning we beat Texas in first round down in KC would put us as a 6 according to his rankings. Now, other teams would play into that but I don't see us getting past a 6. Maybe if we win out we'd get a 5 but thats probably doubtful.

If we did something crazy we could bump up all the way up to a 5. By crazy, I mean something like...

OSU (W)
@Baylor (W)
Tech (W)
Baylor (W)
Kansas (L)

It's nice we're playing well but this is obviously extremely unlikely. Tonight alone will be a battle.
 
Last edited:
If we did something crazy we could bump up all the way up to a 5. By crazy, I mean something like...

OSU (W)
@Baylor (W)
Tech (W)
Baylor (W)
Kansas (L)

Echoing the scenario above assuming #5 Iowa State starts off against #4 Texas --

1646235795312.png

Iowa State ends up as the highest #5 seed.

#4s = Illinois, UCLA, Providence, Alabama
#5s = Iowa State, UConn, Arkansas, Texas
 
I know it's Palm who isn't great...but he continues to be, in my mind, good at seeing the outliers and putting them where they should be.

Iowa State is now a 6 with Ohio State losing and dropping to a 7. Michigan State also dropped to a 7. Iowa a 9.

 
I think we're locked into a 7 worst case no matter results. Could get up to a 5 with a nice run in KC.
 
Will someone explain to me how ISU is a 7-9 seed while these teams are consistently rated ahead of us?

Iowa State: Q1 wins: 9, Q1+Q2 record: 10-9 with no bad losses

Iowa: Q1 wins: 1, Q1+Q2 record: 7-8 and no bad losses
Ohio St: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Nebby
USC: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 10-4 and one bad loss to Stanford
LSU: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Ole Miss
Mich St: Q1 wins: 4, Q1+Q2: 11-9 with one bad loss to Northwestern

These are all teams we need to actively cheer against.
 
Will someone explain to me how ISU is a 7-9 seed while these teams are consistently rated ahead of us?

Iowa State: Q1 wins: 9, Q1+Q2 record: 10-9 with no bad losses

Iowa: Q1 wins: 1, Q1+Q2 record: 7-8 and no bad losses
Ohio St: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Nebby
USC: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 10-4 and one bad loss to Stanford
LSU: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Ole Miss
Mich St: Q1 wins: 4, Q1+Q2: 11-9 with one bad loss to Northwestern

These are all teams we need to actively cheer against.
I agree, especially considering what we saw when the committee released their top 16. I'm surprised more analysts aren't using that as a guide. The chairman mentioned Quad 1 wins for every team during the reveal, so it's obvious those are major factors in seeding. A lot of bracketologists are emphasizing the NET rankings and KenPom. I think they're overemphasizing.

There is simply no way we are on the 8/9 as of now. But some people can't see past the metrics.

I think we're a 6/7 with a chance to move up in the next two weeks.
 
Will someone explain to me how ISU is a 7-9 seed while these teams are consistently rated ahead of us?

Iowa State: Q1 wins: 9, Q1+Q2 record: 10-9 with no bad losses

Iowa: Q1 wins: 1, Q1+Q2 record: 7-8 and no bad losses
Ohio St: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Nebby
USC: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 10-4 and one bad loss to Stanford
LSU: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Ole Miss
Mich St: Q1 wins: 4, Q1+Q2: 11-9 with one bad loss to Northwestern

These are all teams we need to actively cheer against.

It is more accurate to say as it sits at this moment ISU is a 6-7 seed
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jayshellberg
Will someone explain to me how ISU is a 7-9 seed while these teams are consistently rated ahead of us?

Iowa State: Q1 wins: 9, Q1+Q2 record: 10-9 with no bad losses

Iowa: Q1 wins: 1, Q1+Q2 record: 7-8 and no bad losses
Ohio St: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Nebby
USC: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 10-4 and one bad loss to Stanford
LSU: Q1 wins: 5, Q1+Q2: 9-8 with one bad loss to Ole Miss
Mich St: Q1 wins: 4, Q1+Q2: 11-9 with one bad loss to Northwestern

These are all teams we need to actively cheer against.
Iowa: NET rating
Ohio St: NET rating
USC: NET rating
LSU: NET rating
Michigan St: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
  • Like
Reactions: dahliaclone
  • Dumb
Reactions: dahliaclone
  • Agree
Reactions: dahliaclone
It doesn't help when CBS's Jon Rothstein is calling us overachievers...

See, I'm fine with saying we've overachieved. Our overall record exceeds the per possession performance of our team.

But we're not the only ones! The below plot shows how every team that is top 100 in Barttorvik's metric average compares against their resume average:
  • Close to the line - achieved (metrics and resume align)
  • Above the line - underachieved (metrics outperforming resume)
  • Below the line - overachieved (resume outperforming metrics)
1646241876881.png

There are plenty of other teams "overachieving" who don't get near the same credit for it as we do. Credit not exactly being the best word to use, but you get it.
 
I think some people got burned taking ISU in past tournaments so they want to revel in how painful it has been.
 
Bracketville has ISU now a 6 seed facing the winner of a play-in game between San Fran and Indiana.