There are some things that I am far more willing to overlook than others. A college student drinking a bit is one of them. It's when someone's actions really affect others that I have the problem. Underage possession is not something I care about in the slightest. Public intox is often stupid too, although you usually have to be doing something else stupid to get one. I think Jared had already played his final season when he got in trouble for the VEISHEA thing.
The same reasoning applies to Vroman and his bit of pot. I also wouldn't have given a crap about Barryman getting caught in a bar underage if not for the fact that he had previously mugged someone (I wouldn't have let him back on the team after that).
Vandalizing other people's property certainly affects them, and OWI has the potential to be exceptionally bad. There are certainly worse things though and I'm on the fence as to whether Taylor should stay on the team.
Great post, agree completely.