I can't defend my bad voting but you're barking up the wrong tree with me. "Random".org can suck a fat one. Just reg inno here.
***Avatar: the Last Airbender Mafia***
- Thread starter Cleaver
- Start date
I hadn't looked at this thread since getting booted, and was about to quote that the same way.
Remind me again why gipper? He did have votes for both Moores and Fitzy on days 3 & 4. There are certainly others with worse voting records. I already mentioned Dandy, but Azhuth’s also isn’t very good.
For me, worse voting record doesn't mean they're mafia. Either A) they're innocent and therefore don't know who's mafia which can lead to a bad voting record B) they're mafia and didn't want to vote for their own in fear of them getting voted out or C) they're mafia and didn't want us to be able to look for the mafia on mafia votes that happen all the time.
Gipper's mafia votes were placed in the middle of the votes moores and fitzy received. That could mean he's trying to blend in.
Dandy's voting record is suspect, and i know they push back as inno regularly but eventually they're going to be mafia right? The lean on random.org can always be used as a crutch so i never love that reasoning, personally.
I am not confident one way or another on pack, more people seem to have a feeling on him, and I'm willing to listen.
But I am leaning dandy at this point.
I am not confident one way or another on pack, more people seem to have a feeling on him, and I'm willing to listen.
But I am leaning dandy at this point.
Vote Colorado for reasons that have been discussed. I'd still like to get other people's thoughts on gipper though.
Don't disagree, only thing that holds me up on gipper is his vote on moores was to put him up 2 if I am reading the first page correctly. probably not necessary.
Being that I & mdk both had more than a single vote and were still close at that point. I'd understand it if it was just mdk and moores, cuz then he has to just pick a mafia and stay with it. But I was there for him to choose also, which is an inno to take out pretty early in the game.
For now I'm leaning inno on gipper, but I have several people more inno than him in my mind.
I am always amazed with the logic some of you have in this game. If I vote always innocent, I'm mafia. If I vote Mafia, I was just trying to blend in.
Take a look at Days 3, 4 ,and 5.
Day 3: At the time of my vote, it is 4-3 Moores. I vote Moores making it 5-3 for a mafia member.
Day 4: At the time of my vote, it is 5-4 Fitzy. I vote Fitzy making it 6-4 for a mafia member.
Day 5: I refuse to join in the North lynching.
I still believe pack is mafia, I don't see, based on his spotty voting record, that he can be confirmed innocent.
Vote pack attack
