Magic Johnson only averaged 18ppg in NBA Finals for his career in a high scoring era so I don't think an 18 point game is remotely "bad" for a Kidd or Nash or Tyrese or Magic type of plyer. If Tyrese has 10+ assists in Game 7 I'll feel good about Indiana's chances regardless of how much he scores. If he has 25 and 3 assists I'd probably assume they lost.
I like the Magic comparisons because he's the best example of how to be a superstar while still being a distributor. For comparison between all the guys you mentioned, here are their averages through their first 37 playoff games started in their careers (Tyrese's current number):
| Age Range | PPG | APG | RPG | TOPG | FG% | 3P% |
Tyrese | 23-24 | 18.1 | 8.6 | 5.3 | 2.2 | 47 | 35 |
Magic | 20-23 | 17.5 | 9.3 | 10.6 | 3.7 | 50 | 12 |
Kidd | 23-28 | 15.4 | 9.4 | 6.6 | 3.3 | 40 | 23 |
Nash | 23-28 | 16.4 | 7.2 | 3.6 | 2.8 | 44 | 46 |
Obviously it's tough to compare across eras and such, but Tyrese pretty clear fits among that group.
IF the pacers win, mvp probably comes down to who has the better game 7…Siakem or TH. If OKC wins, it’s definitely SGA.
I get the Hali criticism. Superstars can’t just disappear for a couple games in the finals. He sometimes plays too passive and can be a liability on defense at times. I think the late game heroics kind of thrust him into being one of the faces of the league. And he’s just not there yet. He’s still a top 20 player, just not top 5. Needs to be more consistent. That said, he’s still the best ISU nba player ever and the consistency will come.
I'm curious and excited to see how Tyrese comes out next season. I truly believe that his stretch in the first half of last season was more than just a flash in the pan (averaging 24/4/13 on 50/40/87 shooting in the first 35 games). But between his all-NBA push last year, the playoff run, the Olympics, and the Pacers' early-season injuries giving him a heavier load, Tyrese really hasn't had a chance to rest in the last year and a half since he had his initial injuries last season. Even beyond his recent calf issue, I'd bet that his previous hamstring and back issues are still affecting him some.
At the same time, I doubt he'll ever average those volume numbers again other than in a small stretch, since guys like Nesmith and Nembhard have improved, and those numbers were pre-Siakam. But at the very least, Tyrese's playoff shooting has been uncharacteristically inefficient, and I think he can/will grow there.