2025 Portal Activity

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,640
63,705
113
Not exactly sure.
I don’t know how anyone could think Campbell is gonna go wild in the portal. We pursue less than anyone. Because:

A) we can’t afford it
B) Campbell prefers to develop talent

Everyone giving Sama such a hard time needs to remember he’s just a sophomore. He has elite speed. I’d prefer to keep him around and see if he can improve.

That being said, we will of course be opportunistic with the players that are available, but they’re going to continue to come from places like Princeton & Eastern Michigan.
I want to use Sama more as the swing pass, jet sweep kinda guy. Like that receiver we got that was UNI track. Use his speed as the back end stretcher.
 

Die4Cy

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2010
14,972
15,857
113
I don’t know how anyone could think Campbell is gonna go wild in the portal. We pursue less than anyone. Because:

A) we can’t afford it
B) Campbell prefers to develop talent

Everyone giving Sama such a hard time needs to remember he’s just a sophomore. He has elite speed. I’d prefer to keep him around and see if he can improve.

That being said, we will of course be opportunistic with the players that are available, but they’re going to continue to come from places like Princeton & Eastern Michigan.
Campbell understands the importance of culture at a place like ISU. The portal can be used for depth, but when spending big money acquiring pieces from elsewhere you are inviting in a dynamic that makes cohesion more difficult. Plus, ISU won't have the money to compete for multiple top targets in the portal every year anyway. Use NIL funds like we have, rewarding top players and filling holes from places where coming to the Big 12 is a step up in competition, and build the core of your team through recruiting high school players.
 

Cfinnerty16

Visual Analytics Czar
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jul 26, 2021
2,251
4,678
113
West Des Moines
Some names from the portal to keep an eye on who could help the team (I'll edit this once I do more research):

RB Sevion Morrison (Kansas)
RB Nate White (Wisconsin) - Could be a good replacement for Jackson. We recruited White out of HS. Pretty sure he visited ISU at least once.
WR Xavier Townsend (UCF) - Former ISU commit. Would be a perfect guy to replace Noel in the slot and as a returner. #1 on my portal wish list.
WR Damien Alford (Utah) - 6'6" guy who missed the season with an injury.
WR Luke Wysong (New Mexico) - This kid is damn good. Reminds me a lot of Josh Lenz.
WR Caleb Medford (New Mexico) - 6'2" athletic guy with some hops. Really good redzone target. Started career at TCU.
WR Trech Kekahuna (Wisconsin) - Slot WR. 25 catches this year.
OT Ryder Langsdale (Lafayette) - This kid is really really good. Only played 2 years at LT after switching over from defense.
OG Hunter Zambrano (Illinois State) - Another solid o-lineman from a small school that has played really well.
C/G Raheem Anderson (Michigan) - We recruited him hard out of high school.
LB Phoenix Jackson (Fresno State) - Pretty decent LB with experience. My younger son's name is Phoenix so I kinda want this kid to come to ISU.
EDGE Princewill Umanmielen (Nebraska) - Hasn't done much in his 2 years at Nebraska but he is very athletic and quick. His brother has over 10 sacks this year for Ole Miss.
EDGE Nate Johnson (Appalachian State) - 7.5 sacks as a freshman. Only 2.5 sacks this year.
EDGE Clev Lubin (Coastal Carolina) - 9.5 sacks this season.
EDGE DJ Warner (Kansas)
DB John Randle Jr. (Utah) - We recruited him as a running back when he was in HS. Moved to DB this year as a redshirt freshman. Former 4 star.
CB Karon Prunty (North Carolina A&T) - Great freshman year at Kansas and then transferred to NC A&T, where he has started for the last 3 years.
CB Amare Snowden (Wisconsin) - 6'4" corner who saw limited action as a freshman this year.
S Caleb Wisniewski (North Dakota State) - All-American FCS safety with Malik Verdon size. #2 on my portal wish list.
DB Boogsie Silvera (McNeese State) - Quality DB with a funny name.


And here are some guys in the portal that I am adding just for a goof:

S Willie Nelson (Oklahoma State) - Great name!
OT Gunnar Hansen (Vanderbilt) - I have no idea if this kid is good, but... I'm a huge fan of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
QB Cade McNamara (Iowa) - Hahaha!... HAHAHAHAHA!!!!
RB Eli Sanders (New Mexico) - Kidding. There's no way he is coming back to Ames.
QB Devon Dampier (New Mexico) - Would love to see him come to ISU as a running back, but I can't see him wanting to go somewhere and change positions.
I agree with your 1 & 2 wish list picks. Those are my 2 favorites too. If we could get one of those, mannnn
 
  • Like
Reactions: demoncore1031

Cfinnerty16

Visual Analytics Czar
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jul 26, 2021
2,251
4,678
113
West Des Moines
The reality for us is that we are not likely to be huge portal players. One, because all the larger universities and deeper pockets will take most of the best players.

For the most part, the way we have done the portal has worked out really well. Taken a few (3-4) guys or so a year. I don't think that will change because we are not at the tippy top of NIL and you also have to pay your players while bringing in new ones. I'd rather pay Big Citrus and Cooper more and keep them rather than bring in a guy who may or may not end up being a hit.

If it were me I'd take


1-2 linebackers
1-2 wide receivers
and a safety.


If the money was there, then an OL or DL.
ASU didn’t dump like 10x more money than us in football. 17 out of their starting line up in the CCG were transfers.
 

clonehome

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2006
1,634
3,056
113
Again linebacker. We are playing basically all FCS level backers and that’s being generous to a few. I will give Brezina a pass since he showed flashes but didn’t play enough to get a feel for.
Correct. We lack speed across the board at LB, even before the injuries There is no Mike Rose, Jake Hummel, Marcel Spears or Willie Harvey on the roster. Not even close. Those are the kind of players we need to make this 3-3-5 scheme work. We need an immediate infusion of talent at LB.

We also don’t have a legit rush end which is another key to the 3-3-5. Joey Peterson tries hard but we don’t have a talent remotely close to Will McDonald or Jaquan Bailey. Forget about being a 1st round pick, we don’t have a UFA on the roster at rush end. This scheme requires a difference-maker at that spot.
 

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,640
63,705
113
Not exactly sure.
Correct. We lack speed across the board at LB, even before the injuries There is no Mike Rose, Jake Hummel, Marcel Spears or Willie Harvey on the roster. Not even close. Those are the kind of players we need to make this 3-3-5 scheme work. We need an immediate infusion of talent at LB.

We also don’t have a legit rush end which is another key to the 3-3-5. Joey Peterson tries hard but we don’t have a talent remotely close to Will McDonald or Jaquan Bailey. Forget about being a 1st round pick, we don’t have a UFA on the roster at rush end. This scheme requires a difference-maker at that spot.
Why I said to put weight on bacon and make him a rush end. His best skill is rushing, let him focus on that and get a backer to fill where they had him. You fill two positions with one addition.
 

State2015

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 26, 2016
1,395
3,012
113
This is hilarious. We just played (albeit terribly) in the conference championship. 10 wins. 1 game from the playoffs. And its ‘replace everyone’. Go touch grass you fools. And donate to We Will. If you are, donate more. If you aren’t, GTF outta here with your takes.
I think this needs to be posted on every whining thread between now and september
 

State2015

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 26, 2016
1,395
3,012
113
Also worth mentioning that if you’ve heard of hear of someone’s name that’s in the transfer portal, we will probably not land them. If they’re a well-known name there are probably 30-40 programs that have already outbid us.

Did anyone know of Jayden Higgins when he was in the portal? Those are the guys we’re gonna have to rely on, and diamonds like that aren’t around every year
 

ClonesTwenty1

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2018
17,794
21,813
113
I want to use Sama more as the swing pass, jet sweep kinda guy. Like that receiver we got that was UNI track. Use his speed as the back end stretcher.
I’m okay with keeping Sama if we don’t have to pay his full $200,000 nil fund
 
  • Funny
Reactions: BCClone

Billups06

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 18, 2006
1,519
1,609
113
Correct. We lack speed across the board at LB, even before the injuries There is no Mike Rose, Jake Hummel, Marcel Spears or Willie Harvey on the roster. Not even close. Those are the kind of players we need to make this 3-3-5 scheme work. We need an immediate infusion of talent at LB.

We also don’t have a legit rush end which is another key to the 3-3-5. Joey Peterson tries hard but we don’t have a talent remotely close to Will McDonald or Jaquan Bailey. Forget about being a 1st round pick, we don’t have a UFA on the roster at rush end. This scheme requires a difference-maker at that spot.

That’s been the difference in being a disruptive defense (or lack of disruption recently). We haven’t had an edge that’s able to consistently generate pressure in a 3 man front. We’ve had Bailey, Will McD, Enyi, MJ Anderson through the years and this team doesn’t have any of those guys. Orange is great (and near the top of that list) but he’s primarily an inside guy.

All that said, this was the best scoring defense in the big 12 this year but do need to improve our run defense.

I think our biggest need, or area of improvement, is generating a consistent run game.
 
Last edited:

Aclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 14, 2007
26,870
23,380
113
Des Moines, Ia.
So many horrible takes in this thread, especially in the wake of a turd if a game.

Much of it in the exact same vein as the “Carson Hansen can’t run the ball” complaints last offseason.

And yes, he’s been dinged up most of the season.

News flash? Players develop and improve from year to year, folks.

The injuries on offense (especially OL) and defense took a toll as the year wound down. We were first on the conference in both total offense and defense later in the year.

That many LB injuries was an outlier…times three.

Verdon and Freyler covered for green LB mistakes—until there wasn’t Verdon any more.

The rushing attack was developing nicely until Barrett got hurt. And stayed hurt.

*Hint? Depth on the OL (especially the interior) will be much better with six players coming off redshirts.

Alston and Green weren’t recruited for a huge impact this year, they were sweating up for next. Hello? They literally play the exact same positions as Higgins and Noel.

We need more speed at WR? Who the **** do you think those young guys are that the coaches have been glowing over? That’s not even counting the current signees. Zay Robinson could be a taller Noel.

I don’t know what the current fredhman look like, compared to the coaches who see them every day, but I’d guess a portal list would start with a cirner

Someone to start opposite Jontez, and act as a bridge to some really talented ‘24 recruits. Going by previous learning curves (Jontez included) means they’ll be really good in ‘26.

*”Abu to corner” is basically asking him to redshirt.

Again, without knowing how the young guys look, the next spot could be a Travis-type LT.

The other four spots will likely go something like LG Buhr C Barrett RG Black (/Hasert?) RT Miller.

Townsend would not be a surprise for an M.

A safety is another possibility, but there is loads of seasoned young talent at S. Bringing someone in is screwing them over.

Balance that with playing KState first game.

NG likely depends on whether Big Citrus goes to the NFL or not. He’s not going anywhere else.

And as was already said, it’s more than likely we won’t be bringing in big name P4 transfers. Small school guys looking to make a name for themselves the way Higgins did? There you go.
 
Last edited: