Casey's breakfast pizza... what kind is the best?

Casey's breakfast pizza... what kind is the best?

  • Sausage

  • Bacon

  • Veggie (seriously?)

  • Other

  • It's all trash


Results are only viewable after voting.
Sausage and dip the crust in bacon jam (if I have some in the fridge). Got the recipe from a cook at the omelet station in my office a few years back.

Bacon Jam
1 lb bacon or pork belly
1 white onion
2 cups brown sugar
2 oz soy sauce
2 oz worcestershire sauce
2 oz jalapeno vinaigrette made 1 day before (or just white vinegar with some cayenne pepper thrown in)
2 oz day old coffee
 
I'm at the point where all the mega slices pretty much taste the same. I just grab the biggest one without even looking at what's on it. Haven't been disappointed yet.
 
Sausage and dip the crust in the Bacon Jam (if I have some in the fridge). Got the recipe from a cook at the omelet station in my office a few years back.

Bacon Jam
1 lb bacon or pork belly
1 white onion
2 cups brown sugar
2 oz soy sauce
2 oz worcestershire sauce
2 oz jalapeno vinaigrette made 1 day before (or just white vinegar with some cayenne pepper thrown in)
2 oz day old coffee
I made some bacon jam last week and it was fantastic. Never tried it on pizza
 
They’ll tell you it was a walk of shame leaving and seeing the clerk right there, what it really was was a walk of pride.
Pro move: Make your purchase and leave the merchandise at the end of the counter. That Mountain Dew always tasted a little better after you come strutting through that swinging door letting everyone know you just absolutely murdered that single seater.
 
After reading this thread all morning, I had to stop at Casey's for a lunch slice. I wanted to try the new beer cheese breakfast one, as the ads I see for it all say 'served all day'. I was disappointed to see the Casey's in Kieler, WI didn't have any in the case. Either it's false advertising or maybe it's just so popular they couldn't keep up with demand.

Either way, I enjoyed a large slice of non breakfast sausage pizza instead. Still quite satisfying.
 
That seems to be the problem with Casey's pizzas lately. They all seem to be undercooked to me. The dough is too ... doughy. It could stand to cook for 5 more minutes, IMO.
We went to Carroll a couple weeks ago and one of the small towns just outside had beautifully made and cooked pizza and donuts. You could tell an older lady is the cook, not some wasted punk that doesn't give 2 ***** like in Ankeny. Which blows me away that they don't have quality assurance in the town where they are based.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: khardbored
A little of those salsa packets on your breakfast pizza takes it up a level as well
 
We went to Carroll a couple weeks ago and one of the small towns just outside had beautifully made and cooked pizza and donuts. You could tell an older lady is the cook, not some wasted punk that doesn't give 2 ***** like in Ankeny. Which blows me away that they don't have quality assurance in the town where they are based.
We just recently were introduced to Casey's where I live and now there are like 4-5 stores in my area. The first one opened about a year and a half ago, so they moved fast. I've found the pizza quality is wildly inconsistent. Sometimes, I think it's the best pizza I ever had and sometimes, I think they forgot half the ingredients and didn't cook it nearly long enough. I mean it's wildly inconsistent from store to store, but also within the same store.

When I was younger and lived elsewhere working a job that barely paid minimum wage, I almost lived on Casey's pizza because it was cheap, good and there was a Casey's across the alley from where I lived. I don't remember it being this inconsistent back then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: khardbored
After reading this thread all morning, I had to stop at Casey's for a lunch slice. I wanted to try the new beer cheese breakfast one, as the ads I see for it all say 'served all day'. I was disappointed to see the Casey's in Kieler, WI didn't have any in the case. Either it's false advertising or maybe it's just so popular they couldn't keep up with demand.

Either way, I enjoyed a large slice of non breakfast sausage pizza instead. Still quite satisfying.
I grabbed a beer cheese pizza slice on my way home. I must admit it was pretty tasty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyinthenorth
I
We just recently were introduced to Casey's where I live and now there are like 4-5 stores in my area. The first one opened about a year and a half ago, so they moved fast. I've found the pizza quality is wildly inconsistent. Sometimes, I think it's the best pizza I ever had and sometimes, I think they forgot half the ingredients and didn't cook it nearly long enough. I mean it's wildly inconsistent from store to store, but also within the same store.

When I was younger and lived elsewhere working a job that barely paid minimum wage, I almost lived on Casey's pizza because it was cheap, good and there was a Casey's across the alley from where I lived. I don't remember it being this inconsistent back then.
I’d guess the constant turnover of workers has to squirrel up consistency.
 
Bonus points if you were A) first in line, and B) walked out to a newly-formed line, knowing full well you just created holy agony for the next user.

Double bonus points if you gave them the cocky head nod as you walk by.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron