I would agree with this assessment on Tinsley's talent vs. Tyrese. What doesn't seem to make sense is Jamaal was taken 27th and some think Halliburton will go top five.
My own completely arbitrary 1-100 ranking
Overall ball handling skill:
Monte: 99
Tinsley: 97
Tyrese: 92
Ball security:
Monte: 100
Tyrese: 80
Tinsley: 65
Court vision:
Tinsley: 99
Tyrese: 97
Monte: 90
Drive and kick:
Tinsley: 95
Monte: 90
Tyrese: 80
Creating own offense/getting to the rim:
Tinsley: 90
Tyrese: 75
Monte: 75
3pt Shooting:
Tyrese: 75
Monte: 75
Tinsley: 55
Mid range Shooting:
Monte: 90
Tyrese: 70
Tinsley: 65
On ball defense:
Tinsley: 99 (few better when motivated but could really fall off)
Monte: 90
Tyrese: 85
Disrupting passing lanes and blocking shots as a point guard:
Tyrese: 99
Tinsley: 95
Monte: 70
Rebounding from guard position:
Tyrese: 95
Tinsley: 80
Monte: 65
Leadership qualities:
Monte: 95
Tyrese: 90
Tinsley: 80
It boils down to a pretty tough decision, Tyrese probably is the best in the immeasurable things that can't be coached.
All three I think are incredible pick and roll point guards but it's so much more prevalent in NBA than college that I can't even rank it. Monte is as good as anybody right now setting up pick and roll. The only thing that limits his pick and roll game is his team's center is the team's starting point guard and ball handler.