McDermott (turned down) Ohio State

I still think hiring from within makes the most sense. Give the lead assistant a chance and if he flames out then make a run at a big name next spring.

Hard to sell that when one of the main reasons you let his boss go was recruiting.

I haven't read up on this at all other than tweets etc that have been posted on here. Is Gregg Marshall in the running at all? This seems like the kind of job that would offer enough money and clout for him to pursue.
 
Mcdormat is older than Matta and a way worse coach than Matta. Terrible hire for a program such as Ohio state.
 
  • Useful
Reactions: Dopey
I can't make sense of them offering him. I can make a little sense out of him refusing, but still surprised by it :confused:
 
Really bad move by Smith. If want Matta gone do it after the season or wait a year. Guys that have jobs at places like Creighton, Xavier, Wichita St, Butler etc who are getting paid well and have more job security have less incentive to leave for a job like OSU where they won't have much security and they pay now isn't as big of deal because these schools are paying their coaches really well.
 
Yea, tOSU really crapped the bed there. You don't ditch Matta unless you know the next guy is saying yes. And you don't let it get public unless you know the guy is saying yes. Getting punked by GMac will be tough to recover from. Need to really back up the truck now, or just give it away to an assistant.
Well, tOSU really doesn't have exclusive rights to hosing up the hiring process. Plenty of other "elite" schools have depended on their name to guarantee a hire, especially when they make it public that they are after someone.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: CycoCyclone
doesn't McD have a daughter that's in high school? would be tough move when you're already making great $$$$.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: isu83
Hard to sell that when one of the main reasons you let his boss go was recruiting.

I haven't read up on this at all other than tweets etc that have been posted on here. Is Gregg Marshall in the running at all? This seems like the kind of job that would offer enough money and clout for him to pursue.

No harder than trying to sell McDermott or another retread or unknown from a mid major. It's hindsight, but this is probably how it should have gone after Matta was fired -

Put out some feelers to the big names on your list - Miller, Mack, etc. If there's some interest from those camps, then be prepared to bust out the checkbook and pay whatever it takes to get them to Columbus. If there's no interest from those names, then you promote from within, burn a year with that guy, and in March or April you make the big splash hire. It's always going to be really tough to pull a coach away from an established program, but it's virtually impossible when you're trying to do it in mid-June.

As it is now, Smith is in between a rock and a hard place. He can't sell the fanbase on a middling candidate like McDermott and he can't draw a big name, at least not without massively overpaying since he doesn't really have an leverage now that he's already had one offer publicly rejected.

Gregg Marshall makes upwards of 3 mil annually at Wichita State, and they're joining a conference that isn't a one bid league next year. Not much incentive for him to leave.
 
No harder than trying to sell McDermott or another retread or unknown from a mid major. It's hindsight, but this is probably how it should have gone after Matta was fired -

Put out some feelers to the big names on your list - Miller, Mack, etc. If there's some interest from those camps, then be prepared to bust out the checkbook and pay whatever it takes to get them to Columbus. If there's no interest from those names, then you promote from within, burn a year with that guy, and in March or April you make the big splash hire. It's always going to be really tough to pull a coach away from an established program, but it's virtually impossible when you're trying to do it in mid-June.

As it is now, Smith is in between a rock and a hard place. He can't sell the fanbase on a middling candidate like McDermott and he can't draw a big name, at least not without massively overpaying since he doesn't really have an leverage now that he's already had one offer publicly rejected.

Gregg Marshall makes upwards of 3 mil annually at Wichita State, and they're joining a conference that isn't a one bid league next year. Not much incentive for him to leave.

I agree. Either way there's no way to pollish this turd now. I've always thought Smith is a pretty smart guy. He's made some great hires in his time at tOSU but he looks like a moron on this deal. I just can't believe he didn't have somebody pretty good on the hook before he pulled the rug on Matta. I wonder if we'll find out at some point that he had his guy lined up and they got cold feet. Matta has been disappointing the last 2 years but he had enough equity built up to stay on through this season. If Smith wanted to go the assistant route then they should've had Matta take a year of leave for medical reasons and seen how the assistant did. At least that way it wouldn't have quite the stench of failure attached to it that it does now.

You're exactly right that tOSU has no bargaining power given the timing of this fiasco. I think Marshall would jump for a enough zeroes but as you said, you're probably going to overpay for whoever you get at this point. His ego would fit in well at tOSU