This is getting rediculous. All the sudden half of the Roosevelt basketball team transfers to Valley. A few years ago one of the top wrestlers in the state up and transfers to Valley. Jason Scales parents lived in Pennsylvania when he played at Valley. Not sure how many kids transfer to Valley just for the sports. I see their state titles as very hollow. The rest of the schools (Minus Dowling) play with the kids that grow up and go to that school. I know there is a school that took Wesley Staten in that does the same thing. Jeff Horner appears to be a better recruiter at this point than Fran at Iowa.
Valley High School Recruiting????
- Thread starter Knownothing
- Start date
Saw someone posting on Twitter all of the athletes that live in the Hoover district yet go to WDM schools (including Darboh and Jok), it was pretty eye opening. The transfer rules in this state are rediculous and just invite this kind of stuff. In Florida, if you go to school out of district, you have to sit out a full year, even if you are transferring to a private boarding school. Even if you move you normally have to sit out unless you can provide a ton of paperwork...
If the parents/guardians truly move into the West Des Moines district and/or all of the open enrollment guidelines are followed, what is the problem? Who can blame them, and why shouldn't they have the freedom to move and go to school where they want?
It's only "recruiting" if Valley initiated the contact. Is Valley contacting kids and convincing them to come to Valley? Find out that happened and then you've got something.
It's only "recruiting" if Valley initiated the contact. Is Valley contacting kids and convincing them to come to Valley? Find out that happened and then you've got something.
This is why I admire Ankeny for their decision to go with two smaller high schools instead of one huge high school. Unlike West Des Moines, our community chose to do what is best for the kids instead of worrying about all the state titles our football and basketball teams will miss out on.
It's recruiting if Horner contacts Joks guardians friend. Who contacts Joks Guardian who tells Peter to transfer. Their are ways around all of this crap. I actually like the way Ankeny does their sports. Good program. For the record. Nobody is moving to West Des Moines. Everyone is moving to Waukee. Except great athletes who move to West Des Moines.
You would think that with the largest enrollment in the state that they would be able to find five guys that can play basketball without bringing in kids from other schools.....BUT.... it is happening everywhere. Even kids in the smaller disticts are open enrolling in neighbring towns because they have a better wrestling team, football team, etc.
I am will to give Valley the benefit of the doubt until I find out that they are actually "recruiting" kids. It could just be kids and/or their parents searching for the best program.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I though the decision was to split the grades, not the students. So there is no South Ankeny, North Ankeny rivalry - it's still Ankeny. This still keeps the athletics together as one community, and no offense, they were definitely worried about state titles for the sports programs.
I don't think there is any proof to say that there is recruiting going on, but the kids aren't stupid. If I live in a school district with a horrible athletic program and there is a powerhouse program 15-20 min away, I would seriously consider trying to relocate or transfer there. It's human nature to want to win.
JMO but Sour grapes. If a kid wants to go to a school that has better athletics programs than the current kids school he/she should be able to. I live in Ames, but Gilbert school district if my kid wanted to go to a bigger/better school mainly for sports I would be all for it.
2 schools open in 2013 and at that point there will be 2 seperate schools and teams.
You think maybe these kids just wanted to play for a guy that played at a high level at Iowa and in the NBADL? Or the fact that they all transferred when Horner became the head coach? I guarantee none of them would be there if our old coach was still coaching there.
Oh, and…
Oh, and…
But there should be some consequence attached to it... Fine, if you want to transfer, do it... but be prepared to sit out a year.
Not everything always is as it appears. I changed schools my senior year so I know how most of this happens. If you transfer aka open enroll, you must sit one school quarter. This is why most move. Show some sort of residency in that district. Ic west and wsr with wrestling are the two most notable schools for kids moving in. If kids want it and are committed I don't see a problem.
I always said it was the best thing that happened to me. I only moved because my original school closed.
Ok, that is new news for me. I'll be honest, I don't get too concerned about this stuff, but I do recall this being a debat when these proposals were being discussed.
I give Ankeny credit here, but then I think you may find that everyone goes to one school and the other looses out. Or, it becomes the Cedar Rapids of sports, where every other year, one of the schools seems to make a run at the playoffs while the others are left out.
There's no doubt of "unofficial" recruiting going on - especially between Valley and Dowling. But there's no doubt the commitment by parents to place their kids in programs they feel will benefit them the most. This even means relocating the whole family to do so, not just open enrolling.
This is FALSE! I went to Valley (same grade as Scales) and was in the weight room freshman year when Scales and his mom came in to talk to the coaches. At the beginning of freshman year it was not known how good he would be.
