This is my view. We got to the right result but the process was a total disaster.
I agree with this on multiple levels:
1. Despite what I’ve been saying, Balogun should have probably been given a yellow card in the field for that play.
2. VAR protocols should have been followed, in which there never would have been a challenge in the first place, or instead the ref would have been shown the video at full speed instead of the cherry-picked images, in which no ref would have ever been issued.
3. There should have been a protocol in which USA could challenge the red card, but because none existed, it went unchallenged.
4. Days later, FIFA upheld the red card, but then a day before the game reversed course and suspended the sentence, screwing over Belgium in their preparation.
5. Because FIFA waffled on this decision, they allowed outside political pressure to be perceived as an overwhelming influence to make an unpopular change, whether that influence had any affect or if the change was correct or not.
The bottom line is FIFA has handled this whole thing about as horribly as possible at every single level, and as a result of how they handled it ensured somebody was going to get screwed over.