***Tiger King Mafia Thread!***

So on day 5 there were 10 people who voted for cmjh instead of CYme. Of those ten, five people voted for either CoKane or Gblade on day 2, which makes them less suspicious (DSMcy voted Gblade, and clonies, PSY, Dandy, and vikes voted CoKane). Two others are out of the game (CYme and Cyfan13). That leaves Andy, Colorado, and Azhuth as people who voted for cmjh on day 5 and did not have a vote day 2 to help their case. I can’t tell much useful info from days 4 and 6, and day 3 was unanimous.
With all that said, I’ll vote Colorado
 
I’m leaning Andy. Anyone give me a reason to think otherwise? I feel like there’s a mafia that’s been pretty silent and Andy kinda fits that bill. I know it’s a healthy choice to some extent to be silent early on though.
I'm guessing there's 2 or 3 mafia left going by the 25-30% percentages....there's still a lot of people left so it would be beneficial for the mafia to lay lower until the numbers were more in their favor.

That being said, I don't think andy fits the bill. North does, but I don't see evidence that would lead me to think he's mafia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JM4CY
Day 2: CoKane had 5 votes and Gblade had 4 votes when Andy placed this 2nd vote on Colorado



Day 5: With CYme at 9 votes and cmjh at 7 votes, Andy placed the 8th vote on cmjh



On top of that, Andy has been mostly silent.

I'll vote Andy.
That theory sounds better than anything I can come up with. Vote Andy.
 
I'm guessing there's 2 or 3 mafia left going by the 25-30% percentages....there's still a lot of people left so it would be beneficial for the mafia to lay lower until the numbers were more in their favor.

That being said, I don't think andy fits the bill. North does, but I don't see evidence that would lead me to think he's mafia.
Some (don't remember now) suggested that there was a good chance North was innocent based on no one coming to his rescue late. I'm not saying that he's for sure innocent though; if there are only a few mafia left, good chance they'd lay low regardless.
 
I’m not sure if we learned much on day 6 other than we shouldn’t have voted CyArob out.
Going back to day 5’s vote between CYme (mafia) and cmjh (unknown), there were some late votes for cmjh, possibly trying to save CYme? I’m looking at andybernard (7:56) and Colorado (8:30). Anyone have thoughts on those two?
I believed that CyArob was innocent so went with the other leading vote getter. Easy as that
 
So on day 5 there were 10 people who voted for cmjh instead of CYme. Of those ten, five people voted for either CoKane or Gblade on day 2, which makes them less suspicious (DSMcy voted Gblade, and clonies, PSY, Dandy, and vikes voted CoKane). Two others are out of the game (CYme and Cyfan13). That leaves Andy, Colorado, and Azhuth as people who voted for cmjh on day 5 and did not have a vote day 2 to help their case. I can’t tell much useful info from days 4 and 6, and day 3 was unanimous.
With all that said, I’ll vote Colorado
Flimsy at best. All of these votes out here today for Andy, who is in your group with me, and you decide to throw out an alternate theory to take heat off of Andy. Mafia move

vote bsaltyman
 
I’m not sure Andy is the right one but I believe there’s one lying low. That I can’t come up with anything else that makes sense.

Vote Andy
 
Flimsy at best. All of these votes out here today for Andy, who is in your group with me, and you decide to throw out an alternate theory to take heat off of Andy. Mafia move

vote bsaltyman
So you’re voting for me not because of some way I voted in the past but because I voted for you today. The last person to do the same thing was CYme.
 
***unofficial vote count***
5 - andybernard: PSY (1354), azhuth (1403), srj (1445), oldman (1509), JM4CY (1724)
3 - dandy: cmjh (947), DSMCy (1011), mj4cy (1444)
2 - CycloneNorth: cubs (733), farnsy (1136)
1 - bsalty: colorado (1626)
1 - cmjh: andybernard (1430)
1 - colorado: bsalty (1451)

1 inconclusive vote from Vikes for (d)andy
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldman
It sucks when you're innocent, looking for the best theories floating around, and the strongest one you find is against you.

Why are people voting for Dandy?