Exactly what I was saying to Cydkar. Sure, in hindsight you can see players that were not appropriately ranked, the few exceptions, but that is not recruiting. Cydkar is one of those stars don't matter, point to an anomaly types. If hindsight was logic, we would all be rich.
Where did you get that from? I'm pretty much the opposite...I'm a star watching/top 150 guy all the way. I've been following recruiting since the 80's. I even lined Van Coleman's pockets subscribing to his newsletter back in the day.