Realignment Megathread (All The Moves)

davegilbertson

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2011
1,856
1,866
113
42
Ironically my best friend is a rational Hawkeye fan who only starts losing sight of reality when Iowa plays ISU or when they're having a particularly good year - and was even happy for me in ISU's Fiesta Bowl year as well as their NCAA run this year.

They're like unicorns, but they do exist.
Most attended the university and don't post online
 

Cloneon

Well-Known Member
Oct 29, 2015
3,005
3,120
113
West Virginia
This is such an example of what is wrong with this country. You a non lawyer think that you are somehow better equipped to give a legal judgement then an actual laywer based on the fact that you did some internet research. This is like when people come into the hospital and try to tell me how to do my job because they googled their symptoms
Both sides have 'systemic' flaws.
 

snowcraig2.0

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 2, 2007
12,550
10,352
113
47
Cedar Rapids, IA
This is such an example of what is wrong with this country. You a non lawyer think that you are somehow better equipped to give a legal judgement then an actual laywer based on the fact that you did some internet research. This is like when people come into the hospital and try to tell me how to do my job because they googled their symptoms
I would never come to the hospital and tell you how to do your job. Clearly you know the best way to clean the bathrooms, and I respect that.....
 

StPaulCyclone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 9, 2008
2,545
2,456
113
Duh!
I posted something similar in the other thread. Promoting G5 schools is more future competition for ISU to remain in the "power conference(s)"
Right, and in some cases they have larger alumni bases and larger TV markets. it’s crazy, we took the four we had to just to survive and it’s paying off. Anyone else is dangerous at this point.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,647
7,505
113
True, but ESPN and OuT EXPECTED the Big12 to dissolve. It didn't because the R8 were both angry and desperate enough to hold together.

If this is tried in the ACC, they (ESPN/Fox) will plan better - ie get 4 teams each to SEC & B1G, and those 8 are enough to dissolve. They might even talk to the left behinds beforehand and tell them not to panic, soft landing spots available in Big12.

So it's not getting past he GoR, it's eliminating them beforehand with smarter prep.
Do you really think Espn and Fox are going to "work together" in any shape or form when it comes to any of this? They are the definition of enemies in this. Same goes with The SEC and B1G.

They will both want the same schools, they will both want the same values. etc. No way they sit down together and take turns picking teams or some crazy thing like that.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: HoopsTournament

RustShack

Chiefs Dynasty
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 27, 2010
13,912
8,402
113
Overland Park
There are only two realistic scenarios for leaving the ACC. 1, they leave when the GoR expires. 2, enough of the schools know they have a better landing spot and vote to dissolve the ACC.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 2speedy1

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,647
7,505
113
Because letting the GOR expire gets them nothing. Letting it get to court a nonzero risk of disaster and if they win, right back to a dead ACC with no chance of that changing. And enough schools agreeing without you, resulting in dissolution, likely a years long court drama in which you’re playing in lower than the American while it’s settled.

Settlement is not only the safest path, it is their only way to leverage the GOR for altering their realignment fate and pay.

A slight premium to the horrible 2016 era deal and a spot in the 3rd super conference is an easy decision. They should be asking for ACC to be made the base of 3rd conference, which given ESPN’s low offer on keeping PAC together, isn’t yet out of question.

If espn was our sole rights holder for next 14 years, you better believe we’d sell OUT for free to have ESPN kill PAC and ACC, roll their leftovers to Big 12, and giving us a premium to balance of our deal. We’d likely give up the premium if needed. Hell, we’re likely still trying to give OUT away for that
That still takes years of litigation and negotiations to get to a settlement.

You keep repeating this like you think everyone just walks in and agrees on something and shakes hands and leaves happy.

It is obvious you have never had any kind of legal or contract disputes. As someone who has been through several of both, it is a long, LONG process, and usually you don't walk away happy, no matter what side you are one.

A mediator told me once, that his job was not to make everyone happy, it was to make everyone equally unhappy.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,647
7,505
113
Got to find some rational hawkeye fans, they are out there, irrational people are pointless to listen to anyways.
The rational ones you talk about are just good actors.

Those of us that live around these types every day, know that is all an act and their true colors come out when they aren't trying to put on their fake "I cheer for the Cyclones when we aren't playing" act.
 

CascadeClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2009
10,882
13,966
113
Here’s the link: https://frankthetank.org/2022/07/22...olution-to-break-a-grant-of-rights-agreement/

It has nothing to do with B1G fandom (a B1G fan wouldn’t want to argue what he’s arguing anyway lol)

It has nothing to do with seeing USC coming

Find a lawyer who agrees with you and I’ll read it, it’s an interesting topic.

I won't argue the legal / court case part of it, because I tend to agree that if it was fightable/winnable the OuT would be fighting it.

However, contracts CAN be amended if both parties agree. You don't have to go to court and win to have a settlement. If OuT offered the Big12 $500M per year in perpetuity (inflation adjusted too) in exchange for the GoR release, clearly the Big12 would agree to that.

Here's the way I look at it- if you had to bet $100 on the over/under on the ACC GoR lasting until 2036 (or whatever it is), where would you bet? I'm hammering the under...
 
  • Agree
Reactions: isucy86

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,647
7,505
113
His complete lack of understanding of how the legal opinion fits into this decision/situation, and 10 years of going back and forth with him on similar topics.

If you get advice from a lawyer that you should pass on a favorable settlement in favor of risking everything for best case of “didn’t lose”, because they tell you it’s an “ironclad” legal document, or something to that effect, find a different lawyer
While I don't like to overuse the dumb reaction as some do, I do wish we had an Eye Roll emoji.

 

CascadeClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2009
10,882
13,966
113
Do you really think Espn and Fox are going to "work together" in any shape or form when it comes to any of this? They are the definition of enemies in this. Same goes with The SEC and B1G.

They will both want the same schools, they will both want the same values. etc. No way they sit down together and take turns picking teams or some crazy thing like that.

They might. This isn't the cold war; ESPN doesn't need Fox to die. Both sides just want to make more money.

So BOTH sides want the prime content (teams) from the ACC. Better to get some than none, and if the only way to get it is to split it...

Also, I think there could easily be schools that are more valuable to one conference/network than the other, especially considering how the BTN revenue model is so influenced by cable market access. Georgia Tech e.g. is probably about worthless to the SEC, but would have some decent value to the B1G.
 

SEIOWA CLONE

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2018
6,793
6,989
113
63
SIAP, Pretty sure if ND is out of the ACC it only takes 7 to dissolve ACC.
The agreement that ND signed to get into the ACC states that if they "ND" ever join a conference, it must be the ACC. So if ND decided it was in its best interest to join the B10, they would have to buy their way out of their ACC contract.
 

nwcat

Active Member
Jul 20, 2016
57
114
33
There are only two realistic scenarios for leaving the ACC. 1, they leave when the GoR expires. 2, enough of the schools know they have a better landing spot and vote to dissolve the ACC.
If all the schools have a landing spot then this might work. It would take cooperation from the Big10, SEC and Big 12, but if the Big10 and SEC each take 4 that will leave 6 schools on the outside. If the BIg12 could take all six remaining, particularly if the $$ for the now expanded Big12 are better than the existing ACC contract then the six remaining schools would have a difficult time showing damages even if they wanted to enforce the GOR.

I get it that this is likely a long shot, but it would get the B10 and SEC what they want, would get ESPN and FOX what they want and would further solidify the B12.

Just a thought
 

trevn

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 10, 2006
5,489
11,715
113
Eastern Iowa
Iowa fans on the 247 board were appalled at the idea that they wouldn't be a part of a Big 10 break away yesterday. Overall my point was more along the lines of the mid tier team in the conferences are getting pretty big heads because they get the money and could compete with the higher ups, so they act like they're the chosen ones or whatnot. Some of those teams are going to be left behind once Alabama gets sick of footing the bill for Vandy or someone comes calling and tells them, Georgia, Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, Clemson, and Florida State(for example) that they'd pay them even more to pair up with the Big 10s elite to form a coast to coast superleague, but this time without needing to include Northwestern or Purdue.
Are you saying a conference affiliation from a century ago doesn't automatically make you an elite college football program or brand?
 

yowza

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2016
2,094
287
113
The agreement that ND signed to get into the ACC states that if they "ND" ever join a conference, it must be the ACC. So if ND decided it was in its best interest to join the B10, they would have to buy their way out of their ACC contract.
They do have as much money as God, so they could do it.
 

isucy86

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
9,142
7,736
113
Dubuque
There was a Frank the Tank (I think) post by a lawyer that said dissolving the conference probably won’t kill the GOR. It would lower the risk but there would still be a potentially nine figure lawsuit by the Wake Forests assserting that they own the broadcast rights to Ohio State at UNC or Alabama at FSU.
To dissolve the GOR's, does it take 100% of schools to agree or is something like 10 of 14 schools?

I could see it being dissolved if there are new conferences for almost all schools and the Big12's new contract offers higher payouts than ACC's current deal with ESPN. ESPN might actually benefit financially as well.

The Big10 & SEC could make it worth the Big12 taking a few ACC questionable schools with a more lucrative guarantee regarding $ split or teams in CFB Playoff
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CascadeClone

cyIclSoneU

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2016
3,300
4,562
113
Iowa fans on the 247 board were appalled at the idea that they wouldn't be a part of a Big 10 break away yesterday. Overall my point was more along the lines of the mid tier team in the conferences are getting pretty big heads because they get the money and could compete with the higher ups, so they act like they're the chosen ones or whatnot. Some of those teams are going to be left behind once Alabama gets sick of footing the bill for Vandy or someone comes calling and tells them, Georgia, Florida, Texas, Oklahoma, Clemson, and Florida State(for example) that they'd pay them even more to pair up with the Big 10s elite to form a coast to coast superleague, but this time without needing to include Northwestern or Purdue.

The B1G and SEC are charging toward combining for 44 or more schools post-ACC breakup... maybe 32 of them make the break-away league. Maybe closer to 24, or even 16. And I bet that close to 40 of those fanbases are convinced they'll be in it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HoopsTournament