***Official portal tracker thread***

What really rubbed him and his family the wrong way was how blunt it was. No details, no "here are some things you should work on as a young player", no apology, nothing. Basically "we want to go a different direction and we'll email you the papers to sign".

I agree, not a great look.
Is it better for the kid to have that or tell him he has a lot to work on, honor his commitment and then when he’s there tell him he probably will never see the field?

Honestly I would prefer that if it was my kid.
 
I'm not disappointed, I'll support the Cyclones and the guys who are here. Once you transfer away then I wish you failure.
Does that go for assistant coaches as well? Tyler Roehl comes to mind, he left - did you wish him failure. Now that he’s back???
 
I'd argue being the OC at a blue blood program with 30 mil a year to spend might be more desirable than being the HC at Iowa State.
Look at the coaching carousel. There are coordinators from better programs than ISU that took over programs in a lot worse shape than ISU.

 
**** that.

I’m not naive to the reality of college football today, but this is just classless behavior.

I hope kids are sharing these stories far and wide and the programs doing a lot of this ******* crater and the staff end up out on their asses.

If that’s ISU, so be it.
Uuummmmmm……..did you express this when Campbell pulled offers?
 
**** that.

I’m not naive to the reality of college football today, but this is just classless behavior.

I hope kids are sharing these stories far and wide and the programs doing a lot of this ******* crater and the staff end up out on their asses.

If that’s ISU, so be it.
TJ did this when he took over the BB job and it's turned out pretty well. People were pissed when he ran off Bolton and a few others. If s coach doesn't believe in you the that player either had to win over the coach or move on.
 
The reality is pulled offers by new staff is an age old reality.

The NIL loss makes it a bigger deal, but keep in mind we have no recourse over players either.

It’s a business.
Fans are told that all the time now.
It’s a business for everyone now.

The only positive thing from this is that it appears Jimmy has confidence he’s gonna get the players he wants.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyatheart
Uuummmmmm……..did you express this when Campbell pulled offers?
Honestly, I wasn’t aware of it.

Presumably he didn’t pull offers because of a different direction. But if he pulled offers from someone committed because they found someone better? **** him.

I did ******* hate the rumors I heard about Hoiberg essentially managing kids out.

Have a frank conversation about what a kid needs to do to succeed? Sure.

I may be a bit old-school here, but I absolutely believe a coach has a responsibility to the athletes. Unless they earnestly help the kids on their team make an informed decision that is best for them they’re not acting with integrity.

My understanding is that this is what TJ does. If not, **** him too.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: CycloneVet
Honestly, I wasn’t aware of it.

Presumably he didn’t pull offers because of a different direction. But if he pulled offers from someone committed because they found someone better? **** him.

I did ******* hate the rumors I heard about Hoiberg essentially managing kids out.

Have a frank conversation about what a kid needs to do to succeed? Sure.

I may be a bit old-school here, but I absolutely believe a coach has a responsibility to the athletes. Unless they earnestly help the kids on their team make an informed decision that is best for them they’re not acting with integrity.

My understanding is that this is what TJ does. If not, **** him too.
You think all those kids left or didn’t show up for a season just decided to walk away?
 
TJ did this when he took over the BB job and it's turned out pretty well. People were pissed when he ran off Bolton and a few others. If s coach doesn't believe in you the that player either had to win over the coach or move on.
So I remember people being upset Bolton left, but I thought it was a Bolton not liking what he was told was expected of him?

Is that not true?

Obviously Bolton had the talent to be a starter on TJ’s first team. No chance he was run off for lack of basketball ability.