So what's your movie idea?

StClone

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2009
6,310
3,567
113
Wisconsin
The fabulous Christopher Nolan movie production The Odyssey was lamented here by those citing it as another remake of Homer's ancient Greek epic poem the Odyssey. Well, that point can be supported as this link illustrates: https://www.comicbasics.com/all-the...u-need-to-watch-including-nolans-the-odyssey/

A great movie but some say it's a new take on an old theme. So, nothing new under the Sun. My question is do you then have an idea for a movie you could share?

I have a few and here are two I found most fun and possibly workable:


------------------
Following Light


UFOs, UAPs, and alien disclosure have dominated public conversation since the 2017 release of the Nimitz incident and F-18 footage. However, few know that physicist James E. McDonald, Ph.D. (Iowa State) challenged the government's control of the UFO narrative as early as the 1960s.

McDonald built a methodical case for UFO reality by traveling the world, interviewing witnesses, investigating landing sites and photographs, and meticulously recording his findings. His academic rigor threatened powerful interests. Enter Philip J. Klass, another Iowa Stater and electrical engineer who, allegedly working as a CIA asset, systematically destroyed McDonald's credibility. Klass harassed McDonald, discredited his work, and secretly lobbied his university backers to defund his research programs.

The pressure mounted: McDonald's career contracted, his marriage faltered, and he ultimately died by suicide in the Arizona desert—a fate some find suspicious given the circumstances.

This true story has all the ingredients for a gripping thriller: a respected scientist, a shadowy adversary, institutional corruption, and a tragic end. A skilled screenwriter could transform these facts into an X-Files-caliber mystery.


--------------------
What Does Jack Know

I once had a wild idea that consumed my free time but now remains an unrealized dream. I envisioned a semi-Glee-like musical about Jack Trice's ghost returning to befriend and guide a 1955 freshman at Iowa State. Jack whispers wisdom to a lonely farm boy—Harlan—about college, life, and love. The twist: Jack's spectral return carries a secret purpose: to deliver forgiveness. The tone echoes Field of Dreams.

Harlan first encounters Jack's ghost while retrieving a textbook late at night in the State Gym, hearing his voice echo through the building.

Harlan comes from Lorah, Iowa, a dying small town marked by the construction of I-80 and the death of its railroad. His loneliness dissolves through classmates, sports, and studies—but his heart truly awakens when he meets Melinda, a blue-eyed girl from Story City with a red ribbon in her blond hair. Melinda's passion for animals was inspired by meeting Margaret Sloss, Iowa State's first female DVM, prompting her to pursue veterinary medicine. https://iagenweb.org/cass/history/per-atlantic_news_telegraph.htm

The story intertwines Harlan and Melinda's romance with Jack's increasing spectral presence, culminating in a gift of forgiveness.

I drafted bits and ideas for a 'screenplay" and got a friend and music professor for input on six musical numbers. Two remain vivid in my memory: "Campanile Morning" (a romantic ballad) and "What Does Jack Know?" I recall fragments of both the lyrics and melodies—I believe they would have been strong pieces. Tragically, I packed my notes away and later lost them accidentally.

Margaret Sloss's Legacy: Sloss, of the historic Sloss House, was the first female DVM at Iowa State. Known for opening lectures with humor, she once quipped: "A city boy visiting his country cousin found him milking a cow with the pail between his legs. When offered a lesson, the boy asked, 'Could I start with a calf instead?'" (from Suzanna Brown and O.H.V. Stalheim's article, "Dr. Margaret Wragg Sloss: The Past and Future of Women in Veterinary Medicine")

 
Last edited:
Nothing wrong with new ideas, but old themes are common in the sphere of motion pictures.

I'd like to see one about any of the Biblical prophets (Jesus even) that isn't full of extra long shots and poor music.

Jazz musicians from the late 50s, early 60s, jamming in NYC clubs, then driving to New Jersey to record in a Van Gelder studio. Maybe include a scene related to Art Kane's famous 1958 photograph.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StClone
Nothing wrong with new ideas, but old themes are common in the sphere of motion pictures.

I'd like to see one about any of the Biblical prophets (Jesus even) that isn't full of extra long shots and poor music.

Jazz musicians from the late 50s, early 60s, jamming in NYC clubs, then driving to New Jersey to record in a Van Gelder studio. Maybe include a scene related to Art Kane's famous 1958 photograph.
Sermon on the Mount could be a scene in that movie useful for now. I just read a piece on Green Books about a Harlem musician, I think. https://www.britannica.com/topic/The-Green-Book-travel-guide
 
I'd like to see Joyce Carole Oates' short story "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" remade. Probably my favorite short story ever, it was adapted to film many decades ago with Treat Williams and Laura Dern, but it was pretty bad and just looked cheaply done. Would love to see a quality film adaptation with maybe Will Poulter as Arnold Friend, and an Elle Fanning type as Connie. She's a little too old though.
 
I'd like to see Joyce Carole Oates' short story "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" remade. Probably my favorite short story ever, it was adapted to film many decades ago with Treat Williams and Laura Dern, but it was pretty bad and just looked cheaply done. Would love to see a quality film adaptation with maybe Will Poulter as Arnold Friend, and an Elle Fanning type as Connie. She's a little too old though.
Need to check that out as the title is familiar, but nothing more.
 
Not a movie but a spin off series. With how My Name is Earl was canceled on a cliff hanger, have a spinoff called My Name is Earl Jr. Cronicalling tracking down Earl Jr's father.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Daddy Kang
One night I was in peak gummy form and thought a movie that every single line in the movie was a famous/well known/fan-loved line from ANOTHER movie would be awesome. Not just like the tried and true 'You're gonna need a bigger boat' or 'it puts the lotion in the basket' etc...

In my gummy state i thought people would love trying to figure out what movie all the lines were from.

but i didn't have a plot.
 
Not a movie but a spin off series. With how My Name is Earl was canceled on a cliff hanger, have a spinoff called My Name is Earl Jr. Cronicalling tracking down Earl Jr's father.

Not bad, I need to rewatch the whole series, good stuff. "Only her name wasn't Peggy"
 
Last edited:
Make the Jack Trice story a feature film.
I sent out Jack's movie idea to the offices of Ron Howard, Rob Reiner, and some one else in 2010. Never heard back Other university boosters approached movie makers with no results. SOOooooo, that is why I took the approach I did in the op.
 
Last edited: